Bartholomew Andrews,Mathi Raja,Nimit Mishra,Michael P. Zaletel,Rahul Roy
Abstract:The stability of fractional Chern insulators is widely believed to be predicted by the resemblance of their single-particle spectra to Landau levels. We investigate the scope of this geometric stability hypothesis by analyzing the stability of a set of fractional Chern insulators that explicitly do not have a Landau level continuum limit. By computing the many-body spectra of Laughlin states in a generalized Hofstadter model, we analyze the relationship between single-particle metrics, such as trace inequality saturation, and many-body metrics, such as the magnitude of the many-body and entanglement gaps. We show numerically that the geometric stability hypothesis holds for Chern bands that are not continuously connected to Landau levels, as well as conventional Chern bands, albeit often requiring larger system sizes to converge for these configurations.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to verify and extend the applicability of the geometric stability hypothesis in fractional Chern insulators (FCIs), especially in those systems without the Landau - level continuous limit. Specifically, by studying a series of topological tight - binding models, the author explores whether the geometric stability hypothesis is still applicable to these non - Landau - level - limit systems.
### Main problem decomposition:
1. **Validity of the geometric stability hypothesis**:
- The geometric stability hypothesis holds that FCIs are more stable when the single - particle spectrum is similar to the Landau levels. This paper aims to test whether this hypothesis is also applicable to those systems without the Landau - level continuous limit.
2. **Impact of non - Landau - level limit**:
- The author constructs a model without the Landau - level continuous limit by introducing longer - range hopping terms to break the SO(2) symmetry in the conventional Hofstadter model. This helps to study the stability and behavior of FCIs far from the Landau - level limit.
3. **Numerical analysis of the many - body spectrum**:
- By calculating the many - body spectrum of the Laughlin state, the author analyzes the relationship between single - particle metrics (such as the saturation of the trace inequality) and many - body metrics (such as the many - body energy gap and the entanglement energy gap). This helps to understand the changes in the stability of FCIs under different system parameters.
### Research methods:
- **Model selection**: The author uses a generalized Hofstadter model, which contains multiple hopping terms along the principal axis directions (for example, n = 1, 3, 6, 9), and changes the properties of the system by adjusting the coefficients of these hopping terms.
- **Single - particle and many - body metrics**:
- Single - particle metrics include the BZ - averaged trace inequality saturation measure (TISM), the normalized Berry curvature fluctuation, the Fubini - Study metric fluctuation, and the energy - gap - to - bandwidth ratio.
- Many - body metrics include the many - body energy gap, the width of the quasi - degenerate distribution, and the main entanglement energy gap.
### Results and conclusions:
- **Verification of the geometric stability hypothesis**: In some cases, even in systems without the Landau - level continuous limit, the geometric stability hypothesis still holds, but usually a larger system size is required for convergence.
- **Discovery of abnormal behavior**: When approaching the continuous limit, the author observes some abnormal behaviors. For example, in some parameter regions, even if TISM increases, the many - body energy gap does not monotonically decrease, and there are even cases where TISM is zero but the many - body energy gap is small.
In summary, through detailed numerical simulations and theoretical analyses, this paper reveals the applicability and limitations of the geometric stability hypothesis under broader conditions and provides a new perspective for further research on the stability of FCIs.