B. Estienne,N. Regnault,V. Crépel
Abstract:We prove that all the criteria proposed in the literature to identify a Chern band hosting exact fractional Chern insulating ground states, in fact, describe an equivalence with a lowest Landau level defined in curved space under a non-uniform magnetic field. In addition, we design an operational test for the most general instance of such lowest Landau level mapping, which only relies on the computationally inexpensive evaluation of Bloch wavefunctions' derivatives. Our work clarifies the common origin of various Chern-idealness criteria, proves that these criteria exhaust all possible lowest Landau levels, and hints at classes of Chern bands that may posses interesting phases beyond Landau level physics.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: how to identify and understand systems with ideal Chern bands, which can carry the exact ground states of fractional Chern insulators (FCIs). Specifically, the author aims to prove that all existing criteria for identifying ideal Chern bands are actually equivalent to the mapping of the lowest Landau level (LLL) in a curved space under a non - uniform magnetic field. In addition, the author also designs an operational testing method to determine which Chern bands can be mapped to the most general periodic LLL.
### Main problem decomposition:
1. **Unification of existing criteria**:
- The paper proves that all existing criteria for identifying special Chern bands (such as q - ideal and r - ideal bands) can be reduced to a generalized LLL mapping, which takes into account non - uniform magnetic fields and cyclotron metrics.
- Specifically, ideal bands allow non - uniform Berry curvatures, which is equivalent to LLL physics under non - uniform magnetic fields. Vortexable bands describe the change in the Bloch state density profile near its zero point, which corresponds to the LLL equipped with a non - uniform cyclotron metric.
2. **Generality and completeness**:
- The author further proves that the most general periodic LLL can be reproduced by at least one of the currently known special Chern bands, thus indicating that these criteria have covered all possible cases and no new, more general criteria will emerge.
- Therefore, there is a one - to - one correspondence between ideal Chern bands and LLL in curved space.
3. **Practical applications**:
- The paper designs an operational testing method based on the derivatives of Bloch wave functions to determine which Chern bands can be mapped to the most general periodic LLL. This method has a low computational cost and is convenient for practical applications.
### Formula summary:
- Hamiltonian of the lowest Landau level:
\[
H(g,B)=\frac{1}{2\sqrt{g}}\left[\pi_a g^{ab}\sqrt{g}\pi_b - B\right]
\]
where $\pi_a=-i\partial_a - A_a$ is the gauge momentum.
- Form of the Bloch wave function:
\[
\psi_k(x,y)=e^{-\tilde{\rho}(X,Y)}\frac{\phi_k(X,Y)}{N_k}
\]
where $\phi_k(X,Y)$ is a uniform and isotropic LLL wave function defined on the torus, and $\tilde{\rho}(X,Y)$ is a periodic Poisson (or Kähler) potential representing the fluctuating part of the magnetic field.
- Operational test condition:
\[
\partial_a J_k = 0
\]
where $J_k$ is a complex - structure tensor derived from the complex structure of the wave function.
By solving these problems, the paper not only clarifies the common origin of different Chern - band ideality criteria but also provides a specific method for judging whether a Chern band can be mapped to the LLL, which is of great significance for theoretical research and experimental exploration.