Intelligent Reflecting Surface Aided MIMO Networks: Distributed or Centralized Architecture?

Guangji Chen,Qingqing Wu,Wen Chen,Yanzhao Hou,Mengnan Jian,Shunqing Zhang,Jun Li
2024-10-23
Abstract:We investigate the capacity of a broadcast channel with a multi-antenna base station (BS) sending independent messages to multiple users, aided by IRSs with N elements. In particular, both the distributed and centralized IRS deployment architectures are considered. Regarding the distributed IRS, the N IRS elements form multiple IRSs and each of them is installed near a user cluster; while for the centralized IRS, all IRS elements are located in the vicinity of the BS. To draw essential insights, we first derive the maximum capacity achieved by the distributed IRS and centralized IRS, respectively, under the assumption of line-of-sight propagation and homogeneous channel setups. By capturing the fundamental tradeoff between the spatial multiplexing gain and passive beamforming gain, we rigourously prove that the capacity of the distributed IRS is higher than that of the centralized IRS provided that the total number of IRS elements is above a threshold. Motivated by the superiority of the distributed IRS, we then focus on the transmission and element allocation design under the distributed IRS. By exploiting the user channel correlation of intra-clusters and inter-clusters, an efficient hybrid multiple access scheme relying on both spatial and time domains is proposed to fully exploit both the passive beamforming gain and spatial DoF. Moreover, the IRS element allocation problem is investigated for the objectives of sum-rate maximization and minimum user rate maximization, respectively. Finally, extensive numerical results are provided to validate our theoretical finding and also to unveil the effectiveness of the distributed IRS for improving the system capacity under various system setups.
Information Theory
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the impact of the deployment architectures of Intelligent Reflecting Surfaces (IRS) in multi - user MIMO broadcast channels on system capacity, especially the performance differences between two different deployment methods, namely distributed IRS and centralized IRS. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following points: 1. **Theoretical analysis of system capacity**: Through theoretical derivations, the maximum capacities of multi - user MIMO broadcast channels assisted by distributed IRS and centralized IRS are obtained respectively, and their performance under different conditions is compared. 2. **Trade - off between passive beamforming gain and spatial multiplexing gain**: The trade - off relationship between passive beamforming gain and spatial multiplexing gain in two IRS deployment methods under high Signal - to - Noise Ratio (SNR) conditions is studied to reveal which deployment method can provide higher system capacity. 3. **IRS element allocation and transmission design**: In view of the advantages of distributed IRS, an efficient hybrid SDMA - TDMA multiple - access scheme is proposed under high SNR conditions, and how to optimize IRS element allocation to maximize the total rate or the minimum user rate is studied. 4. **Numerical verification**: The validity of theoretical results is verified through extensive numerical experiments, and the effect of distributed IRS on improving system capacity under different system configurations is demonstrated. ### Specific problem description The core problem of the paper lies in determining which of the two different deployment methods, distributed IRS and centralized IRS, can provide higher system capacity in multi - antenna broadcast channels. To this end, the authors have carried out in - depth discussions from the following aspects: - **Theoretical model construction**: Based on the LOS propagation and uniform channel assumptions, the expressions of the maximum capacities under the two IRS deployment methods are derived. - **Performance comparison**: Through strict mathematical proofs, it is revealed that under certain conditions, the system capacity of distributed IRS is higher than that of centralized IRS, especially when the total number of IRS elements exceeds a certain threshold. - **Transmission and resource allocation design**: In view of the characteristics of distributed IRS, an efficient transmission scheme combining the spatial and temporal domains is proposed, and the IRS element allocation problem is solved to maximize the total rate or the minimum user rate. ### Main contributions - **Theoretical analysis**: For the first time, the capacities of distributed IRS and centralized IRS are analyzed in detail from the perspective of information theory, revealing the fundamental differences between them. - **Performance optimization**: A new hybrid SDMA - TDMA multiple - access scheme is proposed, which makes full use of the spatial multiplexing gain and dynamic beamforming gain of distributed IRS. - **Numerical verification**: Through a large number of numerical experiments, the correctness of the theoretical analysis is verified, and the advantages of distributed IRS in practical applications are demonstrated. In summary, this paper aims to reveal the performance differences between distributed IRS and centralized IRS in multi - user MIMO broadcast channels through theoretical analysis and experimental verification, providing an important reference for the design of future 6G wireless networks.