Spin-valley entangled quantum Hall states in graphene

Nikolaos Stefanidis,Inti Sodemann Villadiego

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.108.235137

2023-09-14

Abstract:We investigate interaction-driven integer quantum Hall states realized in Landau levels of monolayer graphene when two out of its four nearly degenerate spin-valley flavors are filled. By employing a model that accounts for interactions beyond pure delta-functions as well as Zeeman and substrate-induced valley potentials, we demonstrate the existence of a delicate competition of several phases with spontaneous generation of spin-valley entanglement, akin to the spontaneous appearance of spin-orbit coupling driven by interactions. We encounter a particular phase that we term the entangled-Kekulé-antiferromagnet (E-KD-AF) which only becomes spin-valley entangled under the simultaneous presence of Zeeman and substrate potentials, because it gains energy by simultaneously canting in the spin and valley spaces, by combining features of a canted anti-ferromagnet and a canted Kekulé state. We quantify the degree of spin-valley entanglement of the many competing phases by computing their bipartite concurrence.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Strongly Correlated Electrons

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **To understand the properties of the interaction - driven integer quantum Hall states that appear in Landau levels and their spontaneously generated spin - valley entanglement phenomenon when two spin - valley degrees of freedom are filled in graphene**.

Specifically, the authors studied the characteristics of integer quantum Hall states when two of the four approximately degenerate spin - valley flavors are filled in monolayer graphene. By introducing a model that can describe interactions beyond pure δ - function interactions, Zeeman effect, and substrate - induced valley - symmetry - breaking potential, they demonstrated the subtle competition among multiple phases and discovered the spontaneously generated spin - valley entanglement phenomenon.

### Main problem summary:
1. **Understand the phase diagram of integer quantum Hall states**: In particular, under strong magnetic fields, integer quantum Hall states in graphene exhibit complex phase behaviors, especially in the Landau level with N = 0.
2. **Explore the spin - valley entanglement phenomenon**: Investigate how the system spontaneously generates spin - valley entanglement under specific conditions (such as when both the Zeeman effect and the valley - symmetry - breaking potential exist).
3. **Discover new quantum states**: In particular, the quantum state named "entangled - Kekulé - antiferromagnetic" (E - KD - AF), in which spin - valley entanglement occurs only when both the Zeeman effect and the valley - symmetry - breaking potential exist.

### Specific methods:
- Use the Hartree - Fock variational energy functional to describe the energy of the system and calculate the bipartite entanglement degree (concurrence) to quantify the spin - valley entanglement degree among different phases.
- Introduce a model that can describe long - range interactions, going beyond the pure δ - function interaction model commonly used in previous studies.

### Key results:
- Discovered a new quantum state - E - KD - AF, which tilts simultaneously in spin and valley spaces to gain energy advantages, thus leading to spin - valley entanglement.
- Proved that under certain conditions, the ground state of the system will change from a non - entangled state to an entangled state, which provides a new perspective for understanding the quantum Hall effect in graphene.

### Conclusion:
This research reveals the complexity and diversity of integer quantum Hall states in graphene, especially the spontaneous generation mechanism of spin - valley entanglement. This discovery not only helps to deeply understand the quantum Hall effect in graphene but also provides a new theoretical framework and experimental direction for future research.

Hope this summary is helpful for you to understand this paper! If you have more questions or need further explanations, please feel free to let me know.