Focusing of high energy electron beam using crystal lenses for applications in radiotherapy

Marta Monikowska,Marcin Patecki

2023-08-24

Abstract:The two dominant radiotherapy methods are either simplified in terms of beam generation and handling, which compromises the energy deposition curve in tissues (photon therapy), or require extensive accelerator facilities and complex beam delivery systems to provide a favorable shape of the energy deposition curve (hadron therapy). The advantages of both of these methods, such as the low cost of the apparatus, ease of beam generation, and a suitable shape of the energy deposition curve in tissues, can potentially be achieved by using a very high-energy electron beam (beam energy in the order of a few hundreds of MeV) focused on the area of the tumor lesion. However, focusing of the beam is usually done with the use of quadrupole magnets which makes the beam delivery system complex and challenging from the engineering point of view. In this thesis, the feasibility of an alternative solution is explored, where focusing is performed by a bent silicon crystal with an appropriate shape of its exit face. Such a crystal lens can be a very light object (mass in the order of grams), allowing for much simpler beam delivery systems of radiotherapy facilities. As a result of this feasibility study, a simulation of a bent silicon crystal with profiled exit was prepared in Geant4. The outcome obtained from the simulation proved the focusing ability of such profiled crystal. However, the focusing strength of the crystal is not strong enough. Technical requirements needed to enable an improvement in focusing efficiency were identified and understood. Moreover, alternative solutions providing stronger focusing while using profiled crystals were proposed.

Accelerator Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems Addressed by the Paper

The paper primarily explores the use of very high energy electron beams (VHEE) in radiotherapy and the method of focusing these beams using crystal lenses. Specifically:

1. **Limitations of Existing Radiotherapy Methods**:
- Photon therapy (such as X-rays or gamma rays) has lower equipment costs and is easier to operate, but its energy deposition curve is suboptimal, irradiating healthy tissue surrounding the tumor.
- Heavy ion therapy (such as protons or carbon ions) can precisely concentrate the dose on the tumor but involves complex and expensive equipment.

2. **Advantages and Challenges of High Energy Electron Beams**:
- Very high energy electron beams (several hundred MeV) can combine the low cost of photon therapy with the energy deposition advantages of heavy ion therapy.
- However, traditional quadrupole magnet focusing methods make the equipment complex and difficult to implement.

3. **Crystal Focusing Technology**:
- The paper proposes an alternative method of focusing electron beams using bent silicon crystals. These crystal lenses can be very lightweight (a few grams), simplifying the engineering design of the entire system.
- Simulations using Geant4 software indicate that bent silicon crystals do have focusing capabilities, but the focusing strength is insufficient.

4. **Improvement Proposals**:
- The paper identifies the technical requirements needed to improve focusing efficiency and proposes alternative methods to enhance the focusing effect.

In summary, the paper aims to evaluate a new radiotherapy technique that optimizes the energy deposition of high energy electron beams in the tumor area using crystal focusing technology, thereby achieving efficient and low-cost treatment.