Common Firm-level Investor Fears: Evidence from Equity Options

Jozef Barunik,Mattia Bevilacqua,Michael Ellington

2023-09-08

Abstract:We identify a new type of risk, common firm-level investor fears, from commonalities within the cross-sectional distribution of individual stock options. We define firm-level fears that link with upward price movements as good fears, and those relating to downward price movements as bad fears. Such information is different to market fears that we extract from index options. Stocks with high sensitivities to common firm-level investor fears earn lower returns, with investors demanding a higher compensation for exposure to common bad fears relative to common good fears. Risk premium estimates for common bad fears range from -5.63% to -4.92% per annum.

General Finance

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores a new type of risk—common firm-level investor fears—and identifies this risk through stock option data. Specifically, the key points of the paper include:

- **Research Background**: Existing research typically uses stock index options to measure overall market uncertainty or fear, but there is less research on how individual stock options reflect firm-level uncertainty and how this uncertainty affects stock returns.

- **Definition and Classification**: The paper categorizes firm-level fears into two types: "good fears" (associated with stock price increases) and "bad fears" (associated with stock price decreases). This information is different from the market fear extracted from index options.

- **Empirical Findings**:
- By analyzing a large amount of individual stock option data, the paper finds that the higher the sensitivity of a stock to common firm-level investor fears, the lower its expected return.
- Investors require higher compensation for exposure to "bad fears" compared to "good fears." The estimated risk premium ranges from -5.63% to -4.92% per year.

- **Methodology**: The study employs Principal Component Analysis (PCA) to extract common factors and uses a model-free approach to calculate implied volatility from individual stock option prices, which is then decomposed into "good fears" and "bad fears."

- **Comparative Analysis**: The paper also compares common firm-level fears with market fears, finding that while they are related, there are still significant differences.

In summary, the main purpose of this paper is to reveal the informational content of firm-level investor fears and their impact on stock returns, emphasizing the importance of "bad fears" in risk premiums.