Saturation of the anomalous Hall effect at high magnetic fields in altermagnetic RuO2

Teresa Tschirner,Philipp Keßler,Ruben Dario Gonzalez Betancourt,Tommy Kotte,Dominik Kriegner,Bernd Buechner,Joseph Dufouleur,Martin Kamp,Vedran Jovic,Libor Smejkal,Jairo Sinova,Ralph Claessen,Tomas Jungwirth,Simon Moser,Helena Reichlova,Louis Veyrat

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/5.0160335

2023-09-02

Abstract:Observations of the anomalous Hall effect in RuO$_2$ and MnTe have demonstrated unconventional time-reversal symmetry breaking in the electronic structure of a recently identified new class of compensated collinear magnets, dubbed altermagnets. While in MnTe the unconventional anomalous Hall signal accompanied by a vanishing magnetization is observable at remanence, the anomalous Hall effect in RuO$_2$ is excluded by symmetry for the Néel vector pointing along the zero-field [001] easy-axis. Guided by a symmetry analysis and ab initio calculations, a field-induced reorientation of the Néel vector from the easy-axis towards the [110] hard-axis was used to demonstrate the anomalous Hall signal in this altermagnet. We confirm the existence of an anomalous Hall effect in our RuO$_2$ thin-film samples whose set of magnetic and magneto-transport characteristics is consistent with the earlier report. By performing our measurements at extreme magnetic fields up to 68 T, we reach saturation of the anomalous Hall signal at a field $H_{\rm c} \simeq$ 55 T that was inaccessible in earlier studies, but is consistent with the expected Néel-vector reorientation field.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: In a high magnetic field, whether the anomalous Hall effect (AHE) in RuO₂ (ruthenium dioxide), an alternating magnetic material, will be saturated at a specific critical magnetic field \(H_c\). Specifically, the researchers hope to experimentally verify whether the AHE signal in RuO₂ caused by Néel vector re - orientation will be saturated under high - magnetic - field conditions.

### Background and Problem Description

1. **Anomalous Hall Effect (AHE)**
- The AHE is a macroscopic linear response used to detect time - reversal symmetry breaking in the electronic structure of magnetic materials.
- The AHE has been observed in conventional ferromagnets and non - collinear magnetic structures, and recent research has been extended to a new class of compensated collinear magnets, called altermagnets.

2. **AHE Characteristics in RuO₂**
- In RuO₂, when the Néel vector is along the [001] easy - axis direction, the AHE is excluded by symmetry.
- When an external magnetic field is applied along the [110] direction, the Néel vector will be re - oriented from the [001] easy - axis to the [110] hard - axis, thus allowing the occurrence of the AHE.
- Early studies have shown that the AHE signal is not saturated in magnetic fields below 50 T, but saturation is expected to occur in higher magnetic fields.

3. **Research Objectives**
- Verify the saturation phenomenon of the AHE signal in RuO₂ by making measurements in an extreme magnetic field of up to 68 T.
- Confirm whether the saturation of the AHE signal is consistent with the Néel vector re - orientation field \(H_c\), which helps to understand the time - reversal symmetry breaking mechanism in altermagnets.

### Experimental Results

- The researchers carried out systematic magnetic and magnetotransport property measurements on RuO₂ thin films and confirmed that the results in magnetic fields below 50 T are consistent with previous studies.
- In magnetic fields exceeding 50 T, saturation of the AHE signal was observed, with the saturation field \(H_c\approx55 \, \text{T}\), which is in line with the expected Néel vector re - orientation field.
- Temperature - dependent magnetotransport data show that at low temperatures, the Hall resistivity decreases as the temperature rises and exhibits a clear saturation phenomenon below 80 K.

### Conclusions

This study not only verifies the early findings regarding the AHE in RuO₂ but also, by extending to a higher magnetic field range (68 T), observes the saturation phenomenon of the AHE signal for the first time. This result provides more complete experimental evidence for the origin of the AHE in altermagnets and further supports the time - reversal symmetry breaking mechanism caused by Néel vector re - orientation.

### Formula Representation

- The relationship between the Néel vector re - orientation angle \(\alpha\) and the magnetic field \(H\) can be approximately expressed as:
\[
\sin\alpha\sim\frac{H}{H_c}\quad(\text{for }H < H_c)
\]
where \(H_c\) is the critical magnetic field strength required to align the Néel vector along the [110] axis.

- The saturation behavior of the Hall resistivity \(\rho_{\text{Hall}}\) indicates that when \(H > H_c\), the AHE signal dominates the ordinary Hall effect contribution.