Abstract:Mixing solutions of oppositely charged macromolecules can result in liquid-liquid phase separation into a polymer-rich coacervate phase and a polymer-poor supernatant phase. Here we show that charge asymmetry in the constituent polymers can slow down the coarsening dynamics, with an apparent growth exponent that deviates from the well-known 1/3 for neutral systems and decreases with increasing degrees of charge asymmetry. Decreasing solvent quality accelerates the coarsening dynamics for asymmetric mixtures, but slows down the coarsening dynamics for symmetric mixtures. We rationalize these results by examining the interaction potential between merging droplets.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **How does charge asymmetry affect the coarsening kinetics during the coacervation process of polyelectrolyte complexes?**
Specifically, the author studied the influence of charge asymmetry on the process of small droplets merging into large droplets (i.e., the coarsening process) in the coacervate phase formed by liquid - liquid phase separation when mixing polymer solutions with opposite charges. Traditional theories predict that for the spinodal decomposition of neutral systems, the coarsening process follows a power - law relationship of \( R \sim t^{1/3} \). However, it has been experimentally observed that in biocondensates and polyelectrolyte complex coacervations, the coarsening kinetics slows down significantly, and the growth exponent is much lower than 1/3.
### Main problems:
1. **What are the specific effects of charge asymmetry on the coarsening kinetics?**
- By simulating the coarsening process of polyelectrolyte coacervations under different charge asymmetry conditions, the paper found that as the charge asymmetry increases, the coarsening kinetics slows down significantly, the growth index drops from close to 1/3 to lower values (such as 0.20, 0.14, 0.10, etc.), and in highly asymmetric systems, the coarsening process may stop completely, forming multiple stable droplets.
2. **How does the solvent quality affect the coarsening kinetics?**
- The paper also explored the influence of solvent quality on the coarsening kinetics. The results show that reducing the solvent quality can accelerate the coarsening process of charge - asymmetric systems, but it cannot restore the \( t^{1/3} \) growth law of neutral systems. For charge - balanced systems, reducing the solvent quality will slightly slow down the coarsening kinetics instead.
3. **What is the mechanism of action of the free - energy barrier?**
- In order to understand the reason for the slowdown of the coarsening kinetics caused by charge asymmetry, the author calculated the potential of mean force (PMF) when two charged droplets merge. The results show that in charge - asymmetric systems, droplet merging needs to overcome a free - energy barrier, and the height of this barrier increases as the charge asymmetry increases.
### Conclusion:
This paper reveals the significant inhibitory effect of charge asymmetry on the coarsening kinetics of polyelectrolyte complex coacervations, and points out that this inhibitory effect originates from the free - energy barrier formed by the electrostatic repulsion between charged droplets. In addition, changes in solvent quality also affect the coarsening kinetics, but in charge - asymmetric systems, even under poor solvent conditions, the coarsening process is still strongly inhibited by electrostatic repulsion.
These findings not only help to understand the kinetic behavior of polyelectrolyte complex coacervations, but may also provide a new perspective for explaining the abnormal kinetics of intracellular biocondensates (such as nucleoli, stress granules, etc.).