Energy gap of the even-denominator fractional quantum Hall state in bilayer graphene

Alexandre Assouline,Taige Wang,Haoxin Zhou,Liam A. Cohen,Fangyuan Yang,Ruining Zhang,Takashi Taniguchi,Kenji Watanabe,Roger S. K. Mong,Michael P. Zaletel,Andrea F. Young

2023-08-11

Abstract:Bernal bilayer graphene hosts even denominator fractional quantum Hall states thought to be described by a Pfaffian wave function with nonabelian quasiparticle excitations. Here we report the quantitative determination of fractional quantum Hall energy gaps in bilayer graphene using both thermally activated transport and by direct measurement of the chemical potential. We find a transport activation gap of 5.1K at B = 12T for a half-filled N=1 Landau level, consistent with density matrix renormalization group calculations for the Pfaffian state. However, the measured thermodynamic gap of 11.6K is smaller than theoretical expectations for the clean limit by approximately a factor of two. We analyze the chemical potential data near fractional filling within a simplified model of a Wigner crystal of fractional quasiparticles with long-wavelength disorder, explaining this discrepancy. Our results quantitatively establish bilayer graphene as a robust platform for probing the non-Abelian anyons expected to arise as the elementary excitations of the even-denominator state.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Strongly Correlated Electrons

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **Determine the energy gap of the even - denominator fractional quantum Hall states in bilayer graphene**.

Specifically, the researchers experimentally measured the energy gap of the fractional quantum Hall (FQH) states in bilayer graphene (Bernal bilayer graphene) and compared it with the theoretical calculation results. They used two different methods to measure the energy gap:

1. **Thermally - activated transport measurement**: By measuring the change in conductivity at different temperatures, determine the energy cost required to create a physically separated quasiparticle - quasihole pair.
2. **Chemical potential measurement**: By directly measuring the change in chemical potential, determine the energy gap of the incompressible state in the partially filled Landau level.

### Research background and motivation

The fractional quantum Hall effect (FQH) is a topological phase - transition phenomenon that occurs in two - dimensional electron systems under a strong magnetic field. Among them, the even - denominator fractional quantum Hall states are considered to be described by non - Abelian anyons, which have non - trivial braiding statistical properties and can be used to realize fault - tolerant topological qubits.

However, previous experimental measurement results in materials such as GaAs have shown that the energy gaps of these states are small, limiting the direct detection of non - Abelian statistical properties. Therefore, the researchers hope to find a larger energy gap in bilayer graphene to verify the existence of these states and further study their properties.

### Main findings

1. **Activated transport measurement**: At \(B = 12 \, \text{T}\), for the half - filled \(N = 1\) Landau level, the measured activated transport energy gap is \(\Delta_{\text{act}}^{\text{qp}} = 5.1 \, \text{K}\), which is very close to the result calculated by the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG).

2. **Chemical potential measurement**: For the same filling factor, the measured thermodynamic energy gap is \(\Delta_{\mu}^{\text{qp}} = 2.9 \, \text{K}\), which is smaller than the result of the activated transport measurement. The researchers attributed this difference to the influence of disorder effects on the thermodynamic gap.

3. **Model explanation**: By introducing the Wigner crystal model, the researchers were able to explain the influence of disorder effects on the chemical potential measurement results and obtained a fitting result consistent with the experimental data.

### Conclusion

This study not only quantitatively established bilayer graphene as an ideal platform for studying non - Abelian anyons, but also showed that the energy gap of the even - denominator fractional quantum Hall states in bilayer graphene is significantly larger than the previous measurement results in other materials. This provides an important experimental basis for further exploring the topological properties of these states.

### Formulas involved

- The energy gap formula for activated transport:
\[
n_{\text{qp}} \propto \exp \left( -\frac{\Delta_{\text{qp}}}{2k_BT} \right)
\]
where \(\Delta_{\text{qp}}\) is the energy gap of non - Abelian quasiparticles, \(T\) is the temperature, and \(k_B\) is the Boltzmann constant.

- The relationship between the chemical potential jump and the quasiparticle energy gap:
\[
\Delta \mu=\frac{e}{e^*} \Delta_{\text{qp}}
\]
where \(e^*\) is the effective charge of quasiparticles and \(e\) is the electron charge.

These formulas and results indicate that the even - denominator fractional quantum Hall states in bilayer graphene have a large energy gap, providing an important clue for further studying non - Abelian anyons.