Scalable Path Level Thermal History Simulation of PBF process validated by Melt Pool Images

Xin Liu,Xingchen Liu,Goldy Kumar,Paul Witherell
2024-03-19
Abstract:In this paper we outline the development of a scalable PBF thermal history simulation built on CAPL and based on melt pool physics and dynamics. The new approach inherits linear scalability from CAPL and has three novel ingredients. Firstly, to simulate the laser scanning on a solid surface, we discretize the entire simulation domain instead of only the manufacturing toolpath by appending fictitious paths to the manufacturing toolpath. Secondly, to simulate the scanning on overlapping toolpaths, the path-scale simulations are initialized by a Voronoi diagram for line segments discretized from the manufacturing toolpath. Lastly, we propose a modified conduction model that considers the high thermal gradient around the melt pool. We validate the simulation against melt pool images captured with the co-axial melt pool monitoring (MPM) system on the NIST Additive Manufacturing Metrology Testbed (AMMT). Excellent agreements in the length and width of melt pools are found between simulations and experiments conducted on a custom-controlled laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) testbed on a nickel-alloy (IN625) solid surface. To the authors' best knowledge, this paper is the first to validate a full path-scale thermal history with experimentally acquired melt pool images. Comparing the simulation results and the experimental data, we discuss the influence of laser power on the melt pool length on the path-scale level. We also identify the possible ways to further improve the accuracy of the CAPL simulation without sacrificing efficiency.
Computational Engineering, Finance, and Science
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: How to accurately predict and verify the thermal history in the laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) additive manufacturing process, especially the shape characteristics of the molten pool, through the improved path - level thermal history simulation method (based on the contact - aware path - level discretization method, namely CAPL). Specifically, the research aims to develop a scalable PBF thermal history simulation method and verify it with the molten pool images obtained from experiments. ### Research Background In the LPBF process, the thermal history of the material has an important impact on its properties, residual stress, and the warping or deformation of parts. These factors are directly related to the quality and performance of parts. Therefore, accurate and efficient thermal history simulation is crucial for understanding and improving the LPBF process. ### Limitations of Existing Methods The existing thermal history simulation methods have the following problems: 1. **High computational complexity**: Many methods require high - resolution time steps and spatial discretization, resulting in excessive computational costs. 2. **Too many assumptions**: Some methods assume that the thermal history is uniform at the path level, thus ignoring the detailed information at the path level and leading to inaccurate downstream simulations (such as warping, residual stress, etc.). 3. **Lack of verification**: Few studies comprehensively verify the path - level thermal history simulation results with experimental data. ### Main Contributions of the Paper To solve the above problems, this paper proposes an improved method based on CAPL (called PBF - CAPL) and makes the following innovations: 1. **Full - area discretization**: To simulate the laser scanning on the solid surface, not only the manufacturing tool path is discretized, but also virtual paths are added to discretize the entire simulation domain. 2. **Voronoi diagram initialization**: To handle overlapping paths, the path segments are discretized using Voronoi diagrams and the element widths are initialized. 3. **Improved conduction model**: Considering the influence of the high - temperature gradient around the molten pool, the original conduction model is modified. ### Experimental Verification The researchers verified the effectiveness of the new method through the nickel - alloy (IN625) molten pool images obtained from NIST's Additive Manufacturing Metrology Testbed (AMMT). The experimental results show that the simulated molten pool length and width are highly consistent with the actual measured values, especially under different laser power conditions. ### Conclusion This paper proposes a new scalable PBF thermal history simulation method and verifies its accuracy through experiments. This method not only improves the simulation efficiency but also can more accurately predict the thermal history in the LPBF process, providing strong support for optimizing manufacturing parameters. ### Key Formulas - **Laser energy input conservation equation**: \[ \sum_{i = 1}^{N}H_i(t)=\alpha P \] where \(H_i(t)\) is the laser energy input term of the \(i\) - th element, \(\alpha\) is the absorptivity, \(P\) is the laser power, and \(N\) is the number of elements exposed to the laser energy input. - **Normalized laser power**: \[ P(t)=\frac{\alpha P}{\sum_{i = 1}^{N}H_i} \] - **Improved conduction model**: \[ Q_{\text{cond}}=kA_{\text{contact}}\frac{\Delta T_{ij}}{\max(d_0, d_{ij})} \] where \(d_0\) is the threshold distance and \(d_{ij}\) is the distance between two elements. Through these improvements, the PBF - CAPL method can more accurately simulate the thermal history in the LPBF process while ensuring efficiency.