Non-modulated pyramid wavefront sensor: Use in sensing and correcting atmospheric turbulence

Guido Agapito,Enrico Pinna,Simone Esposito,Cedric Taïssir Heritier,Sylvain Oberti

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/202346359

2023-09-07

Abstract:Context. The diffusion of adaptive optics systems in astronomical instrumentation for large ground-based telescopes is rapidly increasing and the pyramid wavefront sensor is replacing the Shack-Hartmann as the standard solution for single conjugate adaptive optics systems. The pyramid wavefront sensor is typically used with a tip-tilt modulation to increase the linearity range of the sensor, but the non-modulated case is interesting because it maximizes the sensor sensitivity. The latter case is generally avoided for the reduced linearity range that prevents robust operation in the presence of atmospheric turbulence. Aims. We aim to solve part of the issues of the non-modulated pyramid wavefront sensor by reducing the model error in the interaction matrix. We linearize the sensor response in the working conditions without extending the sensor linearity range. Methods. We developed a new calibration approach to model the response of pyramid wave front sensor in partial correction, whereby the working conditions in the presence of residual turbulence are considered. Results. We use in simulations to show how the new calibration approach allows for the pyramid wave front sensor without modulation to be used to sense and correct atmospheric turbulence and we discuss when this case is preferable over the modulated case.

Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to solve the problems of non - modulated Pyramid Wave - Front Sensor (PWFS) in atmospheric turbulence sensing and correction. Specifically, the author aims to partially solve the problems of non - modulated PWFS by reducing the model error in the interaction matrix and linearize the sensor response within the linear range without expanding the linear range of the sensor. The following is a detailed interpretation:

### Background and Objectives of the Paper

#### Background
Adaptive optics systems (AO) are increasingly widely used in astronomical instruments of large ground - based telescopes, and the Pyramid Wave - Front Sensor is replacing the Shack - Hartmann Wave - Front Sensor as the standard solution for single - conjugate adaptive optics systems. Usually, in order to increase the linear range of the sensor, the Pyramid Wave - Front Sensor will use tilt modulation. However, in the non - modulated case, the sensitivity of the sensor can be maximized, but due to the small linear range, it is difficult to operate robustly in the presence of atmospheric turbulence.

#### Objectives
The objective of this paper is to partially solve the problems of non - modulated Pyramid Wave - Front Sensor by reducing the model error in the interaction matrix. Specifically, the author has developed a new calibration method for modeling the Pyramid Wave - Front Sensor response under partial correction conditions. Through this method, the linearization of the sensor response can be achieved without expanding the linear range of the sensor.

### Method
The author proposes a new calibration method, called SIMPC (Synthetic Partial Correction Interaction Matrix Model), which takes into account the influence of residual turbulence in the working conditions. The core of the SIMPC method is to calibrate the interaction matrix under typical atmospheric residual conditions to reduce the model error between the calibration point and the actual working point. The specific steps are as follows:

1. **Partial Correction Effect**: It has been found that the effect of partial correction on PWFS is similar to that of modulation, that is, it will affect the sensitivity of the wave - front sensor.
2. **Calibration Method**: Based on the above findings, the author proposes a new calibration method, that is, to synthetically generate an interaction matrix model under partial correction conditions. In this way, the actual working conditions can be more accurately simulated, thereby improving the performance of the system.

### Results
Through simulation, the author shows how the new calibration method enables the non - modulated Pyramid Wave - Front Sensor to sense and correct atmospheric turbulence, and discusses in which cases this configuration is superior to the modulated configuration. The results show that:

- **Sensitivity Improvement**: The non - modulated PWFS has higher sensitivity at low - order spatial frequencies, which is particularly attractive for extreme adaptive optics (XAO) systems and differential piston sensing.
- **Linear Range Improvement**: Although the linear range of the non - modulated PWFS is still limited, it has been improved under partial correction conditions.
- **Flat Wave - Front Response**: For a flat wave - front, the non - modulated PWFS has a larger signal amplitude, so more attention needs to be paid to this point in this configuration.

### Conclusion
The new calibration method proposed by the author significantly reduces the model error between the calibration point and the actual working point of the non - modulated PWFS, making the non - modulated PWFS perform better under specific conditions (such as when observing faint celestial bodies). In addition, this method also provides a valuable reference for the design of future adaptive optics systems.

### Formula Display
The formulas involved in the paper include:

- The calculation formula of the interaction matrix:
\[
D_i=\frac{1}{2N}\sum_{j = 1}^{2N}s_j(- 1)^{j + 1}a_i
\]
where \(s\) is the slope vector and \(a\) is the absolute value of the mode amplitude.

- The sensitivity calculation formula:
\[
x_{\text{RMS}}(i)=\sqrt{\frac{1}{N_{\text{sl}}}\sum_{j = 1}^{N_{\text{sl}}}D_i(j)^2}
\]

These formulas ensure that the technical details involved in the paper can be clearly and accurately expressed.