On the large-scale sweeping of small-scale eddies in turbulence -- A filtering approach

Theodore D. Drivas,Perry L. Johnson,Cristian C. Lalescu,Michael Wilczek
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevFluids.2.104603
2023-07-21
Abstract:We present an analysis of the Navier-Stokes equations based on a spatial filtering technique to elucidate the multi-scale nature of fully developed turbulence. In particular, the advection of a band-pass-filtered small-scale contribution by larger scales is considered, and rigorous upper bounds are established for the various dynamically active scales. The analytical predictions are confirmed with direct numerical simulation data. The results are discussed with respect to the establishment of effective large-scale equations valid for turbulent flows.
Fluid Dynamics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the large - scale sweeping phenomenon of small - scale vortices under the action of large - scale flow in high - Reynolds - number turbulence. Specifically, the researchers analyze the Navier - Stokes equations through spatial filtering techniques to reveal the multi - scale characteristics of fully developed turbulence. The paper specifically focuses on the phenomenon that the small - scale components after band - pass filtering are carried by larger - scale flows, and establishes strict upper bounds for various dynamically active scales. The research results are verified by direct numerical simulation data, and the significance of these results for establishing effective large - scale equations applicable to turbulence is discussed. ### Main problems 1. **Is the small - scale structure mainly dominated by the large - scale flow sweeping?** - The core problem of the paper is to explore whether, in the inertial range of high - Reynolds - number turbulence, the small - scale structure can be considered mainly affected by the large - scale flow sweeping, that is, \((\partial_t+U\cdot\nabla)v = 0\), where \(U\) and \(v\) represent the large - scale and small - scale velocities respectively. 2. **How to quantify the error of the sweeping effect?** - Through strict upper - bound analysis, the researchers quantify the error of the large - scale sweeping effect and explore the variation law of this error under different scale separations and high - Reynolds - number conditions. ### Methods and results - **Methods**: - Use spatial filtering techniques to decompose the Navier - Stokes equations, and decompose the velocity field into three parts: large - scale, band - pass filtered, and remaining small - scale. - Verify the accuracy of theoretical predictions through direct numerical simulation (DNS) data. - Establish strict upper bounds, analyze the error of the large - scale sweeping effect, and explore its behavior in the sense of time integration. - **Results**: - Through strict upper - bound analysis, the researchers find that the large - scale sweeping effect gradually becomes dominant in the inertial range, especially when the scale separation is large and the Reynolds number is high. - The numerical simulation results show that the error of the large - scale sweeping effect decreases significantly as the filtering scale decreases, further verifying the theoretical prediction. ### Conclusions - Through strict mathematical analysis and numerical simulation, this research proves that in the inertial range of high - Reynolds - number turbulence, the small - scale structure is mainly affected by the large - scale flow sweeping. This conclusion not only provides a new perspective for understanding the multi - scale characteristics of turbulence, but also lays the foundation for establishing a simpler and more effective turbulence model. ### Formulas - **Navier - Stokes equations**: \[ \partial_t u+u\cdot\nabla u = -\nabla p+\nu\Delta u + f \] \[ \nabla\cdot u = 0 \] - **Evolution equation of the band - pass filtered velocity field**: \[ (\partial_t+\bar{u}\cdot\nabla)u'' = F \] where \(F\) includes other force terms, such as nonlinear terms, pressure gradient terms, viscous terms, etc. - **Upper bound of the large - scale sweeping error**: \[ \|\partial_t u''\|_p = O\left(\left(\frac{\tilde{\ell}}{L}\right)^{\sigma_{2p}-1}\right) \] \[ \|\bar{u}\cdot\nabla u''\|_p = O\left(\left(\frac{\tilde{\ell}}{L}\right)^{\sigma_{2p}-1}\right) \] These formulas and analyses provide an important theoretical basis for understanding the multi - scale characteristics in high - Reynolds - number turbulence.