Comparison of HRV Indices of ECG and BCG Signals

Kavya Remesh,Job Chunkath
2023-07-21
Abstract:Electrocardiography (ECG) plays a significant role in diagnosing heart-related issues, it provides, accurate, fast, and dependable insights into crucial parameters like QRS complex duration, the R-R interval, and the occurrence, amplitude, and duration of P, R, and T waves. However, utilizing ECG for prolonged monitoring poses challenges as it necessitates connecting multiple electrodes to the patient's body. This can be discomforting and disruptive, hampering the attainment of uninterrupted recordings. Ballistocardiography (BCG) emerges as a promising substitute for ECG, presenting a non-invasive technique for recording the heart's mechanical activity. BCG signals can be captured using sensors positioned beneath the bed, thereby providing enhanced comfort and convenience for long-term monitoring of the subject. In a recent study, researchers compared the heart rate variability (HRV) indices derived from simultaneously acquired ECG and BCG signals. Encouragingly, the BCG signal yielded satisfactory results similar to those obtained from ECG, implying that BCG holds potential as a viable alternative for prolonged monitoring. The findings of this study carry substantial implications for the advancement of innovative, non-invasive methods in monitoring heart health. BCG showcases the ability to offer a more comfortable and convenient alternative to ECG while retaining its capacity to deliver accurate and reliable cardiac information concerning a patient's condition.
Signal Processing
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main purpose of this paper is to compare the performance of electrocardiogram (ECG) and ballistocardiogram (BCG) signals in heart rate variability (HRV) metrics, and to explore the potential of BCG as a non-invasive monitoring method for long-term cardiac health monitoring. ### Research Background and Motivation - **Limitations of ECG**: Although ECG provides quick and reliable parameters for diagnosing heart-related issues, it requires multiple electrodes to be attached to the patient's body, which may cause discomfort and affect the quality of long-term recordings. - **Advantages of BCG**: BCG, as a non-invasive alternative, can record cardiac mechanical activity through sensors placed under the bed, offering a more comfortable and convenient method for long-term cardiac health monitoring. ### Research Methods - **Data Collection**: A 3-lead ECG system and two tandem piezoelectric sensors were used in the study to acquire ECG and BCG signals, respectively. - **Preprocessing**: The ECG signals were band-pass filtered to eliminate noise; the BCG signals were first amplified and then band-pass filtered. - **Heart Rate Calculation**: The Pan-Tompkins algorithm was used to detect QRS complexes in the ECG signals, while a specific BCG heartbeat detection method was employed for the BCG signals. - **HRV Analysis**: Based on the processed signals, time-domain and frequency-domain HRV metrics were calculated, including SDNN, RMSSD, pNN50, VLF, LF, and HF. ### Main Findings - The study results showed that BCG signals are highly correlated with ECG signals in HRV metrics, indicating that BCG can be a viable alternative to ECG for long-term cardiac health monitoring. - BCG not only provides HRV metric accuracy comparable to ECG but also offers greater comfort and higher freedom for patients during long-term monitoring due to its non-invasive nature. ### Conclusion In summary, this study demonstrates that BCG, as an effective alternative to ECG, exhibits comparable performance in heart rate variability analysis. It is particularly suitable for scenarios requiring long-term monitoring, providing a new non-invasive solution for cardiac health monitoring.