Abstract:Fe-Co alloys with induced tetragonal strain are promising materials for rare-earth-free permanent magnets. However, as ultrathin-film studies have shown, tetragonal Fe-Co structures tend to a rapid relaxation toward a cubic structure as the thickness of the deposited film increases. One of the main methods of inducing the stable strain in the bulk material is interstitial doping with small atoms, like B, C, or N. In this work, we present a full configuration space analysis in density functional theory approach for (Fe$_{1-x}$Co$_x$)$_{16}$C supercells with a single C impurity in one of the octahedral interstitial positions and for the full range of Co concentrations $x$. We discuss all assumptions and considerations leading to calculated lattice parameters, mixing enthalpies, magnetic moments, and averaged magnetocrystalline anisotropy energies (MAE). We present a comprehensive qualitative analysis of the structural and magnetic properties' dependence on short- and long-range ordering parameters. We analyzed all unique Fe/Co atoms occupancies at all stoichiometric concentrations possible in 2x2x2 supercell based on 2-atom tetragonal representation. We rely on the thermodynamic averaging method and large sample count to obtain accurate MAE values. We reevaluate several chemical disorder approximation methods, including effective medium methods (virtual crystal approximation and coherent potential approximation) and special quasirandom structures method applied to Fe-Co-based alloys. We observe a structural phase transition from the body-centered tetragonal structure above 70% Co concentration and confirm the structural stability of Fe-Co-C alloys in the tetragonal range. We show the presence of a broad MAE maximum of around 50% Co concentration and notably high MAE values for Co content $x$ as low as 25%. In addition, we show a positive correlation between MAE and mixing enthalpy.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems Addressed by the Paper This paper primarily investigates the structural and magnetic properties of Fe-Co-C alloys under tetragonal deformation. Specifically, the authors aim to address the following issues: 1. **Stabilizing the Tetragonal Phase of Fe-Co Alloys**: - Fe-Co alloys under tetragonal deformation have potential applications as rare-earth-free permanent magnet materials. However, experiments show that with increasing film thickness, the tetragonal structure quickly relaxes into a cubic structure. To stabilize this tetragonal phase, the authors explore methods of interstitial doping (such as B, C, or N). 2. **Detailed Analysis of Structural and Magnetic Properties**: - The authors use density functional theory (DFT) methods to perform a full configuration space analysis of (Fe$_{1-x}$Co$_x$)$_{16}$C supercells. They study the variations in lattice parameters, mixing enthalpy, magnetic moments, and magnetocrystalline anisotropy energy (MAE) at different Co concentrations. 3. **Evaluation of Chemical Disorder Approximation Methods**: - The authors reassess several chemical disorder approximation methods, including the virtual crystal approximation (VCA), coherent potential approximation (CPA), and special quasi-random structure method (SQS), to improve the accuracy of theoretical predictions. 4. **Confirmation of Structural Phase Transitions**: - The study investigates the structural phase transition of Fe-Co-C alloys at high Co concentrations, from body-centered tetragonal (bct) to face-centered cubic (fcc) structures, and verifies the stability of the tetragonal phase. 5. **Maximum MAE and Its Relationship with Mixing Enthalpy**: - The authors observe a broad maximum in MAE at around 50% Co concentration, and even at 25% Co content, the MAE value remains significantly high. Additionally, a positive correlation between MAE and mixing enthalpy is found. ### Summary Through detailed DFT calculations, this paper systematically studies the structural and magnetic properties of Fe-Co-C alloys under tetragonal deformation, aiming to provide theoretical support for the development of rare-earth-free permanent magnet materials. The authors not only evaluate the effectiveness of different chemical disorder approximation methods but also reveal the impact of Co concentration on material properties, particularly the maximum MAE and its relationship with mixing enthalpy. These research findings are of great significance for optimizing the performance of Fe-Co-C alloys.

Structural and magnetic properties of Fe-Co-C alloys with tetragonal deformation: a first-principle study

Tunable Interplay Between 3d and 4 F Electrons in Co-Doped Iron Pnictides

Concentration tuned tetragonal strain in alloys: application to magnetic anisotropy of FeNi$_{1-x}$Co$_x$

Structural transformation and magnetic properties of (Fe$_{0.7}$Co$_{0.3}$)$_2$B alloys doped with 5$d$ elements: A combined first-principles and experimental study

Giant magnetocrystalline anisotropy energy in Fe--Co alloy under uniaxial compression: first-principles prediction

First-principles study of the magnetic anisotropy of ultrathin B-, C-, and N-doped FeCo films

From soft to hard magnetic Fe-Co-B by spontaneous strain: A combined first principle and thin film study

Structural Stability and Magnetism of Γ′-Fe4n and CoFe3N Compounds

Thermal and magnetic properties of Fe(Co)BCCu amorphous alloys with high saturation magnetization of 1.77 T

Magnetic hardness of hexagonal and orthorhombic Fe$_{3}$C, Co$_{3}$C, (Fe-Co)$_{3}$C, and their alloys with boron, nitrogen, and transition metals: A first-principles study

Effect of Fe substitution with Co on the magnetic properties of Fe80P13C7 amorphous alloys: An abinitio molecular dynamics study

First-Principles Calculations on Structural and Magnetic Properties of SmCo 3 Alloys Doped with Transition Metal Elements

Tuning magnetocrystalline anisotropy by cobalt alloying in hexagonal Fe3Ge1

Coulomb correlations and magnetic properties of L1$_0$ FeCo: a DFT+DMFT study

Computational studies of structural, mechanical and magnetic properties of the B2-phase Fe50Co50-xCrx magnetic alloys

First-principles Prediction of Enhanced Magnetic Anisotropy in FeCo Alloys

Intrinsic magnetic properties of {$R$(Fe$_{1-x}$Co$_{x}$)$_{11}$Ti$Z$} ($R$ = Y and Ce; $Z$ = H, C, and N)

On the origin of perpendicular magnetic anisotropy in strained Fe-Co(-X) films

Robustness of magnetocrystalline anisotropy and coercivity in Fe–Co–B

Co-based alloys design based on first-principles calculations: Influence of transition metal and rare-earth alloying element on stacking fault energy

Reinvestigation of the intrinsic magnetic properties of (Fe$_{1-x}$Co$_x$)$_2$B alloys and crystallization behavior of ribbons