On the importance of illustration for mathematical research

Rémi Coulon,Gabriel Dorfsman-Hopkins,Edmund Harriss,Martin Skrodzki,Katherine E. Stange,Glen Whitney
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1090/noti2839
2023-11-13
Abstract:Mathematical understanding is built in many ways. Among these, illustration has been a companion and tool for research for as long as research has taken place. We use the term illustration to encompass any way one might bring a mathematical idea into physical form or experience, including hand-made diagrams or models, computer visualization, 3D printing, and virtual reality, among many others. The very process of illustration itself challenges our mathematical understanding and forces us to answer questions we may not have posed otherwise. It can even make mathematics an experimental science, in which immersive exploration of data and representations drive the cycle of problem, conjecture, and proof. Today, modern technology for the first time places the production of highly complicated models within the reach of many individual mathematicians. Here, we sketch the rich history of illustration, highlight important recent examples of its contribution to research, and examine how it can be viewed as a discipline in its own right.
History and Overview
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper explores the importance of illustrations in mathematical research. Specifically, the paper attempts to address the following issues: 1. **The Role of Illustrations in Mathematical Understanding**: The paper emphasizes the various applications of illustrations (including hand-drawn diagrams, computer visualizations, 3D printing, and virtual reality) in mathematical research. These illustrations not only help researchers better understand abstract mathematical concepts but also reveal new mathematical structures and patterns. 2. **Illustrations as Tools for Experimental Science**: The paper points out that through immersive exploration of data and representations, illustrations can make mathematics an experimental science. This experimental nature drives the formulation of problems, the formation of hypotheses, and the process of proof. 3. **The Impact of Modern Technology on Illustrations**: With the development of modern technology, the creation of complex mathematical models has become more widespread and convenient. The paper discusses how these technologies have changed the way mathematical research is conducted and provides many specific examples. 4. **The History and Development of Illustrations**: The paper reviews the important status of illustrations in the history of mathematics, from ancient geometric figures to 19th-century three-dimensional models, and to modern computer visualizations. These historical backgrounds demonstrate the consistent importance of illustrations in mathematical research. 5. **Challenges Faced by Illustrations**: Despite the great potential of illustrations, their creation process also faces many challenges. These challenges include technical difficulties, software learning curves, and the risk of illustrations potentially misleading researchers. The paper discusses how to overcome these challenges to make illustrations more reliable and effective. 6. **The Potential of Illustrations as an Independent Discipline**: The paper argues that illustrations are becoming an independent field of research. By systematically studying and developing illustration techniques, their role in mathematical research can be further enhanced. In summary, this paper aims to emphasize the multifaceted importance of illustrations in mathematical research and explore how to further develop this field through modern technology and systematic approaches.