When greediness and self-confidence meet in a social dilemma

Chaoqian Wang,Wenqiang Zhu,Attila Szolnoki

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physa.2023.129033

2023-07-09

Abstract:A greedy personality is usually accompanied by arrogance and confidence. This work investigates the cooperation success condition in the context of biased payoff allocation and self-confidence. The first component allows the organizer in a spatial public goods game to receive a different proportion of goods than other participants. The second aspect influences the micro-level dynamics of strategy updates, wherein players can maintain their strategy with a certain weight. Analytical results are obtained on square lattices under the weak selection limit. If the organizer attempts to monopolize the public goods, cooperation becomes more attainable. If the confidence increases, cooperation is inhibited. Consequently, these elements have conflicting effects on cooperation, and their simultaneous presence can result in a heterogeneous change of the critical synergy factor. Our theoretical findings underscore the subtle implications of a mutual trait that may manifest as greediness or self-confidence under different circumstances, which are validated through Monte Carlo simulations.

Physics and Society,Statistical Mechanics,Computer Science and Game Theory,Cellular Automata and Lattice Gases

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper examines the changes in the conditions for successful cooperation when selfishness and overconfidence meet in social dilemmas, specifically in the context of biased allocation (participants receiving different proportions of payoffs in a public goods game) and self-confidence (inertia in player strategy updates). Through analysis and Monte Carlo simulations, the study finds that biased allocation can promote cooperation in certain situations, while self-confidence may inhibit cooperation. The paper reveals the complex effects of both factors on cooperation when they coexist and identifies critical synergistic effect factors, providing theoretical evidence for understanding how selfishness and overconfidence affect cooperation.