Superconductivity of Ta-Hf and Ta-Zr alloys: Potential alloys for use in superconducting devices

Tomasz Klimczuk,Szymon Królak,Robert J. Cava
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevMaterials.7.064802
2023-06-18
Abstract:The electronic properties relevant to the superconductivity are reported for bulk Ta-Hf and Ta-Zr body centered cubic alloys, in large part to determine whether their properties are suitable for potential use in superconducting qbits. The body centered cubic unit cell sizes increase with increasing alloying. The results of magnetic susceptibility, electrical resistivity and heat capacity characterization are reported. While elemental Ta is a type I superconductor, the alloys are type II strong coupling superconductors. Although decreasing the electron count per atom is expected to increase the density of electronic states at the Fermi level and thus the superconducting transition temperature (Tc) in these systems, we find that this is not sufficient to explain the significant increases in the superconducting Tc's observed.
Superconductivity,Materials Science
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem this paper attempts to address is the exploration of the potential for improving the superconducting properties of tantalum (Ta) alloys with hafnium (Hf) or zirconium (Zr), particularly whether these alloys are suitable for use in superconducting qubit devices. Specifically, the authors aim to determine whether these alloys exhibit higher superconducting transition temperatures (Tc) and whether they transition from type I to type II superconductors by studying their electronic properties, magnetism, resistivity, and heat capacity. ### Main Research Questions: 1. **Increase in Superconducting Transition Temperature (Tc)**: Whether alloying (i.e., doping with Hf or Zr) can significantly increase the superconducting transition temperature (Tc) of pure tantalum, allowing it to maintain a superconducting state at higher temperatures. 2. **Change in Superconducting Type**: Pure tantalum is a type I superconductor. The study investigates whether Ta-Hf or Ta-Zr alloys transition to type II superconductors after alloying, which would have significant implications for their application in superconducting devices. 3. **Impact on Density of States and Debye Temperature**: The study examines the effect of alloying on the density of states (DOS) and Debye temperature (ΘD) to explain the increase in Tc. 4. **Measurement of Superconducting Parameters**: The superconducting properties of these alloys are characterized in detail using various experimental methods (such as susceptibility, resistivity, and heat capacity measurements), including critical field (Hc), upper critical field (Hc2), coherence length (ξGL), and penetration depth (λGL). ### Research Background: - **Application in Quantum Computers**: Superconducting qubits (Qbits) are crucial components in building quantum computers, and Nb and Ta are commonly used superconducting materials. - **Limitations of Pure Tantalum**: Pure tantalum is a type I superconductor with a relatively low superconducting transition temperature (around 4.4 K), limiting its temperature range for practical applications. - **Potential Advantages of Alloying**: Alloying can adjust the electronic structure, increase the superconducting transition temperature, and improve other physical properties of the material, such as oxidation resistance and mechanical strength. ### Research Methods: - **Sample Preparation**: Ta1-xHfx and Ta1-xZrx alloy samples were prepared using arc melting. - **Structural Characterization**: X-ray diffraction (XRD) was used to determine the crystal structure and lattice parameters of the alloys. - **Electronic Property Characterization**: A physical property measurement system (PPMS) was used to measure susceptibility, resistivity, and heat capacity. ### Research Results: - **Changes in Lattice Parameters**: With increasing Hf or Zr content, the lattice parameters of the BCC phase increased linearly. However, the solubility limit of Zr was lower (about 20-30%), while that of Hf was higher (about 70-80%). - **Increase in Superconducting Transition Temperature**: The Tc of Ta0.8Hf0.2 and Ta0.8Zr0.2 increased to approximately 6.7 K and 7.1 K, respectively, significantly higher than the 4.4 K of pure tantalum. - **Transition to Type II Superconductors**: Pure tantalum is a type I superconductor, while the alloyed Ta-Hf and Ta-Zr alloys are type II superconductors. - **Impact on Density of States and Debye Temperature**: Although the increase in the density of states contributes to the increase in Tc, changes in the Debye temperature are also an important factor affecting Tc. ### Conclusion: - **Improvement in Superconducting Properties**: Alloying can significantly increase the superconducting transition temperature of tantalum-based alloys and transition them from type I to type II superconductors, providing new possibilities for the application of superconducting qubit devices. - **Importance of Debye Temperature**: The impact of changes in the Debye temperature on the superconducting transition temperature cannot be ignored, and further research is needed to verify this conclusion. Overall, this paper reveals the potential advantages of Ta-Hf and Ta-Zr alloys in superconducting properties through detailed experimental and theoretical analysis, providing important references for the design and application of future superconducting materials.