Abstract:Quantum states undergoing quantum chaotic dynamics are expected to evolve into featureless states at late times. While this expectation holds true on an average, coarse-grained level, it is unclear if this expectation applies to higher statistical moments, as symmetries typically present in physical systems constrain the exploration of phase space. Here we study the universal structure of late-time ensembles obtained from unitary dynamics in quantum chaotic systems with symmetries, such as charge or energy conservation. We identify two limiting universal regimes depending on the initial condition. When the initial state is typical -- all the moments of the symmetry operators are equal to those of pure random states -- then the late-time ensemble is indistinguishable from the Haar ensemble in the thermodynamic limit and at the level of higher statistical moments. Otherwise, atypical initial states evolve into non-universal ensembles which can be distinguished from the Haar ensemble from simple measurements or subsystem properties. Interestingly, such atypical initial conditions are not rare, even when considering product state initial conditions, and can be found in the middle of the spectrum of Hamiltonians known to be `maximally' chaotic. In the limiting case of initial states with negligible variance of the symmetry operator (e.g., states with fixed particle number or states with negligible energy variance), the late-time ensemble has universal behavior captured by constrained RMT ensembles. Our work shows that even though midspectrum states do not explore ergodically all of phase space at late times, the late-time ensemble typically -- but not always -- exhibits the same average and sample-to-sample fluctuations as the Haar ensemble.

Stationarity of quantum statistical ensembles at first-order phase transition points

Statistical ensembles for phase coexistence states specified by noncommutative additive observables

Quantum Entanglement As a Diagnostic of Phase Transitions in Disordered Fractional Quantum Hall Liquids

Exceptional Dynamical Quantum Phase Transitions in Periodically Driven Systems

First-order Canonical Phase Transition As Origin of the Non-Equivalence of the Microcanonical and Canonical Ensembles in the Thermodynamic Limit

Intrinsic Jump Character Of First-Order Quantum Phase Transitions

Diagnosing weakly first-order phase transitions by coupling to order parameters

Framework of dynamical transitions from long-range to short-range quantum systems

Dynamics of a Nonequilibrium Discontinuous Quantum Phase Transition in a Spinor Bose-Einstein Condensate

Theory of dynamical phase transitions in quantum systems with symmetry-breaking eigenstates

Phase transitions in the unconstrained ensemble

Observation of Dynamical Quantum Phase Transition with Correspondence in Excited State Phase Diagram

Dynamical quantum phase transitions from random matrix theory

Late-time ensembles of quantum states in quantum chaotic systems

Stability of Quantum Critical Points in the Presence of Competing Orders

Deconfined quantum critical points: a review

Observation of Dynamical Quantum Phase Transitions with Correspondence in an Excited State Phase Diagram

Coherent and dissipative dynamics at quantum phase transitions

Quantum chaos and phase transition in the Yukawa–Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model

Signatures of a quantum phase transition on a single-mode bosonic model