From Electronic Design Automation to Building Design Automation: Challenges and Opportunities

Yu-Wen Lin,Tsz Ling Elaine Tang,Alberto L. Sangiovanni-Vincentelli,Stefano Schiavon,Costas J. Spanos
2023-05-11
Abstract:Design automation, which involves the use of software tools and technologies to streamline the design process, has been widely adopted in the electronics industry, resulting in significant advancements in product development and manufacturing. However, building design, which involves the creation of complex structures and systems, has traditionally lagged behind in leveraging design automation technologies. Despite extensive research on design automation in the building industry, its application in the current design of buildings is limited. This paper aims to (1) compare the design processes between electronics and building design, (2) highlight similarities and differences in their approaches, and (3) examine challenges and opportunities associated with bringing the concept of design automation from electronics to building design.
Other Computer Science
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper discusses the challenges and opportunities of applying the concept and methods of Electronic Design Automation (EDA) to the automation of architectural design. Currently, although EDA is widely used in electronic product design, improving efficiency and innovation, automation in architectural design has not been fully developed, despite some research focusing on automated design of architectural subsystems. The paper first compares the processes of electronic design and architectural design, pointing out that both require multi-stage concept development and iteration, involving collaboration between different professionals and the use of specialized software. However, architectural design has a lower degree of automation due to lack of standardized input-output relationships, difficulties in component reuse, and communication barriers between different design teams. Next, the paper mentions the challenges in the architectural industry, such as the isolation phenomenon in the design process, software tool integration issues, architectural complexity, communication problems, and limited standardization practices. At the same time, it also points out that although integrated frameworks like BIM and energy efficiency standards exist, the architectural industry has not fully adopted integrated design methods. Then, the paper discusses the potential benefits of design automation in the architectural field, such as improving efficiency, accuracy, and cost reduction, and introduces existing automation attempts, such as using machine learning algorithms for design optimization. Despite these efforts, design automation in practical architectural design is still in its infancy. Finally, the paper proposes Electronic Design Automation (EDA) as a reference and analyzes areas where architectural design can draw inspiration from, such as iterative workflows and the use of standardized and integrated tools. By comparing the processes, tools, and industry status of electronic design and architectural design, the paper aims to identify key issues hindering architectural design automation and explore future research directions to achieve design automation in the architectural industry.