The Human-or-Machine Matter: Turing-Inspired Reflections on an Everyday Issue

David Harel,Assaf Marron

2023-08-02

Abstract:In his seminal paper ``Computing Machinery and Intelligence'', Alan Turing introduced the ``imitation game'' as part of exploring the concept of machine intelligence. The Turing Test has since been the subject of much analysis, debate, refinement and extension. Here we sidestep the question of whether a particular machine can be labeled intelligent, or can be said to match human capabilities in a given context. Instead, we first draw attention to the seemingly simpler question a person may ask themselves in an everyday interaction: ``Am I interacting with a human or with a machine?''. We then shift the focus from seeking a method for eliciting the answer, and, rather, reflect upon the importance and significance of this Human-or-Machine question and the use one may make of a reliable answer thereto. Whereas Turing's original test is widely considered to be more of a thought experiment, the Human-or-Machine matter as discussed here has obvious practical relevance. While it is still unclear if and when machines will be able to mimic human behavior with high fidelity in everyday contexts, we argue that near-term exploration of the issues raised here can contribute to refinement of methods for developing computerized systems, and may also lead to new insights into fundamental characteristics of human behavior.

Artificial Intelligence,Human-Computer Interaction

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The core issue this paper attempts to address is "how people determine whether they are interacting with a human or a machine in everyday interactions." Specifically, the authors focus on the importance and significance of this issue rather than seeking a direct method to arrive at an answer.

### Background and Motivation
- **Turing Test**: In his famous 1950 paper "Computing Machinery and Intelligence," Turing introduced the "imitation game" as part of exploring the concept of machine intelligence. Since then, the Turing Test has undergone extensive analysis, debate, improvement, and expansion.
- **Real-world Relevance**: Although the Turing Test is more often seen as a thought experiment, the "Human-or-Machine Matter" has clear practical significance in daily life. As technology advances, machines are increasingly able to simulate human behavior in everyday interactions, making this issue more important.

### Main Issues of the Paper
1. **Do humans care whether the agent they are interacting with is human or machine?**
- Why do they care?
2. **How do human behaviors or emotional states differ when interacting with another human versus a machine that is indistinguishable from a human?**
3. **How can one determine whether an agent is human or machine?**
4. **Will human language and social practices change in this context?**
5. **Will interactions between machines change when one or both participants behave very similarly to humans?**
6. **Will machines indeed become indistinguishable from humans, or will this no longer be an issue because leveraging machine capabilities will take precedence over mimicking human behavior?**

### Research Focus
- **Importance of the Human-or-Machine Matter**: The authors emphasize the importance of this issue in everyday interactions, where a person may be curious whether the agent they are interacting with is human or machine.
- **Future Impact**: As machines become increasingly capable of simulating human behavior in everyday interactions, new social, psychological, functional, and technical issues will become relevant.

### Practical Applications
- **Service Chatbots**: In scenarios such as service chatbots, medical dialogue agents, store service robots, and autonomous vehicles, machines are already capable of performing tasks traditionally done by humans.
- **Identity-Hidden Interactions**: In interactions conducted solely through text or voice, or when the driver of another vehicle cannot be seen, the identity of the agent may be hidden.

### Hybrid Models
- **Hybrid Agents**: In some cases, the agent may be a hybrid of human and machine. For example, a doctor may rely on online searches while consulting a patient, or a vehicle may be autonomously driven while being remotely monitored.

### Behavioral Differences
- **Differences in Human-Machine Interaction**: Research indicates that humans may be more brief, impolite, more likely to abruptly stop or change topics, and even use profanity when interacting with machines.
- **Trust and Relationships**: Studies on human trust in machines, willingness to disclose personal information, development of personal relationships, and empathy towards machine agents suggest that these aspects may be affected by the perception of the agent as a machine.

### Conclusion
- **Relevance of the Human-or-Machine Matter**: As technology advances, this issue will become increasingly relevant in many everyday situations.
- **Future Research Directions**: The authors propose several questions for further research, including how to design effective inquiry strategies and the practical applications of the Human-or-Machine Matter in different contexts.

In summary, this paper aims to explore the importance and practical applications of the "Human-or-Machine Matter" in everyday life, proposing multiple questions and directions for further research.