Complex contagion in social systems with distrust

Jean-François de Kemmeter,Luca Gallo,Fabrizio Boncoraglio,Vito Latora,Timoteo Carletti
2023-05-06
Abstract:Social systems are characterized by the presence of group interactions and by the existence of both trust and distrust relations. Although there is a wide literature on signed social networks, where positive signs associated to the links indicate trust, friendship, agreement, while negative signs represent distrust, antagonism, and disagreement, very little is known about the effect that signed interactions can have on the spreading of social behaviors when higher-order interactions are taken into account. In this paper we focus on processes of complex contagion, such as the adoption of social norms, where exposure to multiple sources is needed for the contagion to occur. Complex contagion has been recently modeled by higher-order networks, such as simplicial complexes, which allow transmission to happen not only through the links connecting pair of nodes, but also in group interactions, namely over simplices of dimension larger or equal than two. Here, we introduce a model of complex contagion on signed simplicial complexes, and we investigate the role played by trust and distrust on the dynamics of a social contagion process. The presence of higher-order signed structures in our model naturally induces new infection and recovery mechanisms. Through numerical simulations and analytical results in the mean-field approximation, we show how distrust determines the way the system moves from a state where no individuals adopt the social behavior, to a state where a finite fraction of the population actively spreads it. Interestingly, the fraction of spreading individuals displays a non-monotonic dependence on the average number of connections between individuals. We then investigate how social balance affects social contagion, finding that balanced triads either promote or impede contagion based on the relative abundance of fully trusted relations.
Physics and Society,Statistical Mechanics,Social and Information Networks
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how trust and distrust relationships affect the complex contagion process in social systems, especially when considering not only pairwise interactions but also higher - order group interactions. Specifically, the researchers constructed a complex contagion model on a signed simplicial complex, aiming to explore the role of trust and distrust in the spread of social behaviors. Through this model, they hope to reveal how trust and distrust relationships affect the spread process of social behaviors from scratch, and how these relationships affect the phase - transition characteristics in the spread process, such as continuous or discontinuous transitions. In addition, the study also explored the influence of structural balance under the social balance theory on the contagion process, and analyzed how different types of triangular relationships (such as all - trust triangles and single - trust triangles) promote or hinder the spread of social behaviors.