István Z. Kiss,Christian Bick,Péter L. Simon
Abstract:Complex contagion models that involve contagion along higher-order structures, such as simplicial complexes and hypergraphs, yield new classes of mean-field models. Interestingly, the differential equations arising from many such models often exhibit a similar form, resulting in qualitatively comparable global bifurcation patterns. Motivated by this observation, we investigate a generalized mean-field-type model that provides a unified framework for analysing a range of different models. In particular, we derive analytical conditions for the emergence of different bifurcation regimes exhibited by three models of increasing complexity -- ranging from three- and four-body interactions to two connected populations with both pairwise and three-body interactions. For the first two cases, we give a complete characterisation of all possible outcomes, along with the corresponding conditions on network and epidemic parameters. In the third case, we demonstrate that multistability is possible despite only three-body interactions. Our results reveal that single population models with three-body interactions can only exhibit simple transcritical transitions or bistability, whereas with four-body interactions multistability with two distinct endemic steady states is possible. Surprisingly, the two-population model exhibits multistability via symmetry breaking despite three-body interactions only. Our work sheds light on the relationship between equation structure and model behaviour and makes the first step towards elucidating mechanisms by which different system behaviours arise, and how network and dynamic properties facilitate or hinder outcomes.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand how complex contagion dynamics are affected by higher - order interactions in high - order network structures. Specifically, the paper explores how the contagion dynamics will change when contagion occurs not only through simple connections between nodes (i.e., two - body interactions), but also through higher - order interactions (such as three - body and four - body interactions) in more complex structures such as simplicial complexes and hypergraphs. The goal of the paper is to provide a unified framework to analyze such complex contagion models that include higher - order interactions and to reveal the different bifurcation behaviors in these models and the mechanisms behind them.
### Analysis of the Core Problems in the Paper
1. **The Influence of Higher - Order Interactions on Contagion Dynamics**:
- Traditional infectious disease models usually assume that contagion occurs along the edges between nodes, that is, two - body interactions. However, in the real world, the contagion process may involve more complex forms of interaction, such as three - body or four - body interactions. How these higher - order interactions affect the dynamics of contagion is one of the core problems of this paper.
2. **A Unified Framework for Different Models**:
- The paper proposes a general mean - field model that can cover many different types of complex contagion models. Through this framework, the author hopes to systematically analyze the behaviors of different models and find the commonalities among them.
3. **Analysis of Bifurcation Behaviors**:
- The author pays special attention to the bifurcation behaviors that may occur in different models when parameters change, such as transcritical bifurcation, bistability, and multistability. These bifurcation behaviors are of great significance for understanding the spread and control of diseases.
### Specific Research Contents
- **Model Construction**:
- The paper constructs a general mean - field model for describing SIS (susceptible - infected - susceptible) dynamics on high - order networks. This model takes into account the effects of two - body, three - body, and four - body interactions and uses polynomial equations to describe the evolution of the system.
- **Bifurcation Analysis**:
- Through the mathematical analysis of the model, the author derives the conditions for different bifurcation behaviors. For example, when the two - body interaction rate \(C_2\) is equal to the recovery rate \(\gamma\), the system will undergo a transcritical bifurcation. If the three - body interaction rate \(C_3\) is greater than \(\gamma\), the system may exhibit bistability.
- **Multi - group Model**:
- The paper also explores the multi - group model, in which the nodes within each group have the same topological characteristics, but different groups may have different interaction patterns. This model can better reflect the complex network structures in the real world.
### Main Findings
- **Single - group Model**:
- For a single - group model that only contains three - body interactions, the system can only exhibit simple transcritical bifurcation or bistability. However, a model that contains four - body interactions may exhibit multistability, that is, there are two different epidemic stable states.
- **Multi - group Model**:
- Even in the case of only containing three - body interactions, the multi - group model may also exhibit multistability due to symmetry breaking. This indicates that the interaction patterns between groups have an important influence on the dynamic behavior of the system.
### Conclusion
By constructing and analyzing the general mean - field model, the paper reveals the important role of higher - order interactions in complex contagion dynamics. These findings not only help to understand the spread mechanisms of diseases but also provide a theoretical basis for designing effective disease control strategies.