Abstract:A toggle switch consists of two genes that mutually repress each other. This regulatory motif is active during cell differentiation and is thought to act as a memory device, being able to choose and maintain cell fate decisions. Commonly, this switch has been modeled in a deterministic framework where transcription and translation are lumped together. In this description, bistability occurs for transcription factor cooperativity, whereas autoactivation leads to a tristable system with an additional undecided state. In this contribution, we study the stability and dynamics of a two-stage gene expression switch within a probabilistic framework inspired by the properties of the Pu/Gata toggle switch in myeloid progenitor cells. We focus on low mRNA numbers, high protein abundance, and monomeric transcription-factor binding. Contrary to the expectation from a deterministic description, this switch shows complex multiattractor dynamics without autoactivation and cooperativity. Most importantly, the four attractors of the system, which only emerge in a probabilistic two-stage description, can be identified with committed and primed states in cell differentiation. To begin, we study the dynamics of the system and infer the mechanisms that move the system between attractors using both the quasipotential and the probability flux of the system. Next, we show that the residence times of the system in one of the committed attractors are geometrically distributed. We derive an analytical expression for the parameter of the geometric distribution, therefore completely describing the statistics of the switching process and elucidate the influence of the system parameters on the residence time. Moreover, we find that the mean residence time increases linearly with the mean protein level. This scaling also holds for a one-stage scenario and for autoactivation. Finally, we study the implications of this distribution for the stability of a switch and discuss the influence of the stability on a specific cell differentiation mechanism. Our model explains lineage priming and proposes the need of either high protein numbers or long-term modifications such as chromatin remodeling to achieve stable cell fate decisions. Notably, we present a system with high protein abundance that nevertheless requires a probabilistic description to exhibit multistability, complex switching dynamics, and lineage priming.

Evolutionary Shaping of Low-Dimensional Path Facilitates Robust and Plastic Switching Between Phenotypes

Double-replica theory for evolution of genotype-phenotype interrelationship

On the evolutionary origin of discrete phenotypic plasticity

Evolution of Robustness and Plasticity under Environmental Fluctuation: Formulation in terms of Phenotypic Variances

Shaping Robust System through Evolution

Direction and Constraint in Phenotypic Evolution: Dimension Reduction and Global Proportionality in Phenotype Fluctuation and Responses

Plasticity-led and mutation-led evolutions are different modes of the same developmental gene regulatory network

A Linear Reciprocal Relationship Between Robustness and Plasticity in Homeostatic Biological Networks

Dimensional Reduction in Evolving Spin-Glass Model: Correlation of Phenotypic Responses to Environmental and Mutational Changes

Stochastic phenotype transition of a single cell in an intermediate region of gene-state switching

Stability and Multiattractor Dynamics of a Toggle Switch Based on a Two-Stage Model of Stochastic Gene Expression

Evolutionary game dynamics in phenotype space

Phenotypic plasticity can be an evolutionary response to fluctuating environments

The evolution of reversible plasticity in stable environments

Statistical physics of a model binary genetic switch with linear feedback

Emergence of phenotypic plasticity through epigenetic mechanisms

Emergence of robustness against noise: A structural phase transition in evolved models of gene regulatory networks

Unifying (simple) models of genetic robustness and evolvability

Relationship among Phenotypic Plasticity, Genetic and Epigenetic Fluctuations, Robustness, and Evolovability; Waddington's Legacy revisited under the Spirit of Einstein

Robustness as an Evolutionary Principle

Phenotypic robustness can increase phenotypic variability after non-genetic perturbations in gene regulatory circuits