Abstract:Simple models, in which genetic robustness is expressed as the probability that a mutation is neutral, appear to offer disparate views of the relationship between robustness and evolvability. If we assume robustness trades off with evolvability, but let environmental and mutational robustness vary across genotypes, we find that evolvability is maximized at intermediate rates of environmental change. On the other hand, if we assume that the robustness of a genotype is fixed, but let the mutational networks connecting such genotypes vary, we find that robustness and evolvability need not trade off, and in fact, evolvability is maximized at intermediate levels of robustness. Here, I reconcile and extend these models. First, I show that even without a hard genotype-level trade-off between robustness and evolvability, selection optimizes phenotypic robustness depending on the rate of environmental change. Moreover, when adaptive landscapes are complex, counter-intuitively, certain increases in environmental stability can increase the frequency of environmentally-robust but mutationally-sensitive genotypes; in other words, some environments favor evolvable generalists. Next, with minor adjustments and re-interpretations, I show that simple models connecting mutational robustness to evolvability can be readily applied to environmental (or developmental) robustness. Then, with further model extensions, I show that even if the probability of neutral mutation is fixed, populations can evolve along the spectrum of robustness and evolvability by evolving the genotype-determined neighborhood of mutationally-accessible phenotypes. Indeed, because it allows for the evolution of increased evolvability without a concomitant increase in genetic load, selection should favor changes in the phenotypic neighborhood over changes in mutational sensitivity.

Robustness as an Evolutionary Principle

Robustness and evolvability: Revisited, redefined and applied

Shaping Robust System through Evolution

Degeneracy: a link between evolvability, robustness and complexity in biological systems

Emergence of robustness against noise: A structural phase transition in evolved models of gene regulatory networks

Innovation and robustness in complex regulatory gene networks

Network Structure and Dynamics, and Emergence of Robustness by Stabilizing Selection in an Artificial Genome

Hadronic form factors in Lattice QCD at small and vanishing momentum transfer

Robust Regulatory Networks

Evolution enhances mutational robustness and suppresses the emergence of a new phenotype: A new computational approach for studying evolution

Gene network robustness as a multivariate character

A network characteristic that correlates environmental and genetic robustness

Reliability of regulatory networks and its evolution

Sloppiness, robustness, and evolvability in systems biology

Reliability of genetic networks is evolvable

Evolution of complex modular biological networks

Robustness During Network Evolution

Emergent Network Structure, evolvable Robustness and non-linear Effects of Point Mutations in an Artificial Genome Model

Enhanced robustness of evolving open systems by the bidirectionality of interactions between elements

Unifying (simple) models of genetic robustness and evolvability

Evolution of Robustness and Plasticity under Environmental Fluctuation: Formulation in terms of Phenotypic Variances