Scientists' Warning on Technology

Bill Tomlinson,Andrew W. Torrance,William J. Ripple
2023-04-22
Abstract:In the past several years, scientists have issued a series of warnings about the threats of climate change and other forms of environmental disruption. Here, we provide a scientists' warning on how technology affects these issues. Technology simultaneously provides substantial benefits for humanity, and also profound costs. Current technological systems are exacerbating climate change and the wholesale conversion of the Earth's ecosystems. Adopting new technologies, such as clean energy technologies and artificial intelligence, may be necessary for addressing these crises. Such transformation is not without risks, but it may help set human civilizations on a path to a sustainable future.
Computers and Society
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the Paper Attempts to Address This paper aims to explore how technology impacts climate change and other environmental issues, and to present scientists' warnings about technology. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following points: 1. **The Dual Nature of Technology**: - While technology brings significant benefits to humanity, it also incurs profound costs. Current technological systems exacerbate climate change and the comprehensive transformation of Earth's ecosystems. - For example, fossil fuel technology has improved living standards but also led to severe environmental pollution and global warming. 2. **The Necessity of Technological Transformation**: - To address these crises, new technologies such as clean energy technology and artificial intelligence (AI) need to be adopted. These technologies not only help reduce carbon emissions and other environmental hazards but may also bring about widespread changes in human activities. - However, this transformation is not without risks but may be a necessary step towards leading human civilization to a sustainable future. 3. **The Limitations of Technology**: - Although technology plays a crucial role in solving environmental problems, it cannot solve all issues on its own. Profound economic, political, and cultural adjustments are also needed, along with new narratives to help people adapt to new lifestyles. - For example, technology alone cannot solve social inequality issues, nor can it completely replace human creativity and judgment. 4. **The Dangers of Current Technology**: - The paper emphasizes the severe harm caused by some current technologies to the environment, such as climate change and ecosystem destruction due to fossil fuel technology. - It suggests that these harmful technologies should be phased out as soon as possible, transitioning to cleaner and more sustainable technological systems. 5. **Risks and Opportunities of Future Technologies**: - While new technologies (such as clean energy and AI) have broad prospects, they may also bring new problems and risks. - For example, electronic waste and the potential threat of superintelligence are important considerations in AI development. - Therefore, technological innovation should be closely integrated with research to prevent potential hazards. 6. **The Importance of Cultural and Social Change**: - In addition to technological advancements, profound social and cultural changes are needed to achieve sustainable development goals. - Encouraging the development and support of new technologies can help people envision and achieve a sustainable future. ### Summary By analyzing the dual nature of technology, the paper emphasizes the necessity and limitations of technological transformation. It calls for multifaceted measures, including phasing out harmful technologies, developing and deploying new technologies, and promoting profound social and cultural changes to address the current environmental crisis.