Reducing Opinion Echo-Chambers by Intelligent Placement of Moderate-Minded Agents

Prithwish Jana,Romit Roy Choudhury,Niloy Ganguly

2023-04-21

Abstract:In the era of social media, people frequently share their own opinions online on various issues and also in the way, get exposed to others' opinions. Be it for selective exposure of news feed recommendation algorithms or our own inclination to listen to opinions that support ours, the result is that we get more and more exposed to opinions closer to ours. Further, any population is inherently heterogeneous i.e. people will hold a varied range of opinions regarding a topic and showcase a varied range of openness to get influenced by others. In this paper, we demonstrate the different behavior put forward by open- and close-minded agents towards an issue, when allowed to freely intermix and communicate. We have shown that the intermixing among people leads to formation of opinion echo chambers i.e. a small closed network of people who hold similar opinions and are not affected by opinions of people outside the network. Echo chambers are evidently harmful for a society because it inhibits free healthy communication among all and thus, prevents exchange of opinions, spreads misinformation and increases extremist beliefs. This calls for reduction in echo chambers, because a total consensus of opinion is neither possible nor is welcome. We show that the number of echo chambers depends on the number of close-minded agents and cannot be lessened by increasing the number of open-minded agents. We identify certain 'moderate'-minded agents, who possess the capability of manipulating and reducing the number of echo chambers. The paper proposes an algorithm for intelligent placement of moderate-minded agents in the opinion-time spectrum by which the opinion echo chambers can be maximally reduced. With various experimental setups, we demonstrate that the proposed algorithm fares well when compared to placement of other agents (open- or close-minded) and random placement of 'moderate'-minded agents.

Social and Information Networks,Computers and Society,Multiagent Systems

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the social problems caused by the phenomenon of echo chambers in the social media age. Specifically, the authors focus on how to reduce the number of echo chambers by intelligently placing moderate - minded agents.

### Core Problems of the Paper

1. **Formation of Opinion Echo Chambers**: On social media platforms, people tend to be exposed to opinions similar to their own, thus forming closed small circles (i.e., echo chambers). This phenomenon will hinder healthy opinion exchanges, spread misinformation, and intensify the formation of extreme views.

2. **Limitations of Existing Methods**: Increasing open - minded agents cannot effectively reduce the number of echo chambers, because these people tend to reach a consensus quickly in the opinion - dynamic process, while close - minded agents are difficult to be influenced.

3. **Proposed Solution**: The paper proposes an algorithm that can maximally reduce the number of echo chambers on the opinion - time spectrum by intelligently placing moderate - minded agents. These moderate - minded agents have a moderate degree of opinion openness and can effectively establish connections between different opinion groups, thus breaking the echo chamber effect.

### Specific Objectives

- **Reduce the Number of Echo Chambers**: By introducing moderate - minded agents, make the interactions between different opinion groups more frequent, thereby reducing the formation of closed small circles.

- **Promote Healthy Opinion Exchanges**: Ensure that more individuals can communicate within a wider range of opinions and avoid the isolation and solidification of extreme views.

### Methodology

The paper uses the Hegselmann - Krause (H - K) bounded confidence model to simulate opinion dynamics and represents the crowd and their neighbor relationships through graph - theory methods. The introduction of moderate - minded agents aims to break the closed opinion networks and promote the mutual influence between different groups.

### Experimental Results

Through various experimental settings, the paper shows that the proposed algorithm is superior to the method of randomly placing other types of agents (such as open - minded or close - minded agents) in reducing the number of echo chambers.

### Conclusion

The research in this paper shows that through the intelligent placement of moderate - minded agents, the number of opinion echo chambers can be effectively reduced, and a healthier and more diversified social opinion exchange can be promoted. This provides a possible intervention means for the government or other regulatory agencies to deal with the problem of opinion polarization on social media.

### Summary

The main contribution of this paper lies in proposing an intelligent placement algorithm based on moderate - minded agents to reduce the phenomenon of opinion echo chambers on social media platforms, thereby promoting healthier social dialogue and opinion diversity.