A note on conjugacy problem for finite Sylow subgroups of infinite linear groups

Pınar Uğurlu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3906/mat-1604-11
2023-04-16
Abstract:We prove the conjugacy of Sylow $2$-subgroups in pseudofinite $\mathfrak{M}_c$ (in particular linear) groups under the assumption that there is at least one finite Sylow $2$-subgroup. We observe the importance of the pseudofiniteness assumption by analyzing an example of a linear group with non-conjugate finite Sylow $2$-subgroups which was constructed by Platonov.
Group Theory
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether all Sylow 2 - subgroups are conjugate in a pseudo - finite Mc - group when there exists a finite Sylow 2 - subgroup. Specifically, the author has proven that in a pseudo - finite Mc - group, if one of the Sylow 2 - subgroups is finite, then all Sylow 2 - subgroups are conjugate and thus are all finite. ### Background of the Paper The Sylow theory was initially developed in the context of finite groups, but later attempts were made to generalize it to infinite groups. Although in some specific families of infinite groups, the conjugacy property of Sylow subgroups still holds, in other cases non - conjugate Sylow \(p\)-subgroups may occur, even in linear groups. However, if there exists a finite Sylow \(p\)-subgroup, then in certain classes of groups (for example, groups with finite Morley rank or locally finite groups), the conjugacy results of Sylow subgroups can be obtained. ### Main Contribution The main contribution of this paper lies in proving that in a pseudo - finite Mc - group, if there exists a finite Sylow 2 - subgroup, then all Sylow 2 - subgroups are conjugate. This result fills an important gap in the Sylow theory in pseudo - finite groups. ### Main Theorem The main theorem of the paper is as follows: **Theorem 3.3**: If a Sylow 2 - subgroup of a pseudo - finite Mc - group \(G\) is finite, then all Sylow 2 - subgroups of \(G\) are conjugate and thus are all finite. ### Proof Idea To prove this theorem, the author assumes that \(P\) is a finite Sylow 2 - subgroup of \(G\) and assumes that there exists another Sylow 2 - subgroup \(Q\) that is not conjugate to \(P\). By choosing \(Q\) such that \(|P\cap Q|\) is maximum, the author uses the properties of pseudo - finite groups and the local finiteness of Sylow subgroups to construct a new pair of Sylow 2 - subgroups \((P_1, Q_1)\) such that \(|P_1\cap Q_1| > |P\cap Q|\) and \(P\) and \(P_1\) are conjugate. This contradicts the maximality of \(|P\cap Q|\), thus proving that all Sylow 2 - subgroups are conjugate. ### Example Analysis The author also analyzes in detail an example constructed by Platonov, showing that in a linear group, even if there exists a finite Sylow 2 - subgroup, the conjugacy of Sylow 2 - subgroups is not necessarily guaranteed. Specifically, Platonov constructed a linear group \(\text{SL}_2(\mathbb{Q})\), in which there are infinitely many non - conjugate Sylow 2 - subgroups, each of order 4. This example further illustrates the difference between pseudo - finite groups and general linear groups. ### Conclusion Through strict mathematical proofs and specific example analyses, this paper reveals the conjugacy property of Sylow 2 - subgroups in pseudo - finite Mc - groups and provides an important theoretical basis for further research on the structure of pseudo - finite groups.