Gravitational wave constraints on Einstein-æther theory with LIGO/Virgo data

Kristen Schumacher,Scott Ellis Perkins,Ashley Shaw,Kent Yagi,Nicolas Yunes

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.108.104053

2023-11-30

Abstract:Lorentz symmetry is a fundamental property of Einstein's theory of general relativity that one may wish to test with gravitational wave observations. Einstein-aether theory is a model that introduces Lorentz-symmetry breaking in the gravitational sector through an aether vector field, while still leading to second-order field equations. This well-posed theory passes particle physics constraints because it modifies directly only the gravitational sector, yet it predicts deviations in the inspiral and coalescence of compact objects. We here, for the first time, put this theory to the test by comparing its gravitational wave predictions directly against LIGO/Virgo gravitational wave data. We construct a waveform model for Einstein-aether theory, EA_IMRPhenomD_NRT, through modifications of the general relativity IMRPhenomD_NRTidalv2 model (used by the LIGO/VIRGO collaboration). This model constructs a reponse function that not only contains the transverse-traceless polarization, but also additional Einstein-aether (scalar and vectorial) polarizations simultaneously. We then use the many current constraints on the theory to construct non-trivial priors for the Einstein-aether coupling constants. After testing the waveform model, we conduct parameter estimation studies on two gravitational wave events: GW170817 and GW190425. We find that these data are not sufficiently informative to place constraints on the theory that are stronger than current bounds from binary pulsar, solar system and cosmological observations. This is because, although Einstein-aether modifications include additional polarizations and have been computed beyond leading post-Newtonian order, these modifications are dominated by (already-constrained) dipole effects. These difficulties make it unclear whether future gravitational wave observations will be able to improve on current constraints on Einstein-aether theory.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to test Lorentz symmetry violation within the framework of the Einstein - æther theory using LIGO/Virgo gravitational wave data. Specifically, the researchers constructed a new gravitational - wave waveform model, EA_IMRPhenomD_NRT, which not only includes the traditional transverse - trace polarization but also incorporates additional Einstein - æther (scalar and vector) polarizations. By comparing this model with the gravitational - wave data observed by LIGO/Virgo, the researchers hope to constrain the coupling constants in the Einstein - æther theory.

### Research Background
Einstein's general relativity is the fundamental theory for describing gravity, and one of its core assumptions is Lorentz symmetry. However, some quantum gravity models predict that Lorentz symmetry may be violated under high - energy conditions. The Einstein - æther theory is a theory that introduces a single vector field (æther field) to break Lorentz symmetry while maintaining the second - order nature of the equations. This theory has been constrained in multiple astrophysical observations, but gravitational - wave observations provide a new method to further test these theories.

### Research Methods
1. **Constructing the Waveform Model**: Based on the IMRPhenomD_NRTidalv2 model in general relativity, the researchers constructed a new waveform model, EA_IMRPhenomD_NRT. This model takes into account not only the traditional transverse - trace polarization but also the scalar and vector polarizations specific to the Einstein - æther theory.

2. **Parameter Estimation**: Using the Bayesian inference method, the researchers conducted a parameter estimation study on two double - neutron - star merger events (GW170817 and GW190425). They first constructed the prior distributions of the Einstein - æther coupling constants and used these prior distributions to determine the sampling regions in the parameter space.

3. **Data Testing**: The researchers used synthetic data (i.e., data generated according to general relativity and the Einstein - æther theory) to test their waveform model and verify its accuracy and reliability.

### Main Findings
- **Insufficient Current Data**: The study found that the existing LIGO/Virgo data are not sufficient to impose stricter constraints on the coupling constants in the Einstein - æther theory than other observations (such as solar - system and double - pulsar observations). This is because the corrections in the Einstein - æther theory are mainly dominated by dipole radiation, and dipole radiation has already been well - constrained by double - pulsar observations.
- **Future Prospects**: Although the current data are not sufficient to exceed the constraints of other observations, future third - generation and space - based gravitational - wave detectors may provide stronger constraints. In addition, if the sensitivities of black holes in the Einstein - æther theory can be calculated, binary black - hole systems or hybrid neutron - star/black - hole binary systems can also be further studied.

### Conclusion
This study lays the foundation for how to conduct parameter - estimation studies of the Einstein - æther theory in future LIGO/Virgo observations. Although the current data are not sufficient to provide stronger constraints, with the observation of more double - neutron - star merger events and the accumulation of data, future research is expected to achieve better results.