Unitarity, Causality, and Solar System Bounds, Significantly Limit Using Gravitational Waves to Test General Relativity

Alexander Cassem,Mark P. Hertzberg

2024-08-24

Abstract:The prospect of detecting/constraining deviations from general relativity by studying gravitational waves (GWs) from merging black holes has been one of the primary motivations of GW interferometers like LIGO/Virgo. Within pure gravity, the only possible way deviations can arise is from the existence of higher order derivative corrections, namely higher powers of the Riemann curvature tensor, in the effective action. Any observational bounds imply constraints on the corresponding Wilson coefficients. At the level of the action, one can imagine the coefficients are sufficiently large so as to be in principle detectable. However, from the point of view of some fundamental principles, namely causality and unitarity, this is much less clear, as we examine here. We begin by reviewing certain known bounds on these coefficients, which together imply a low cut off on the effective theory. We then consider a possible mechanism to generate such terms, namely in the form of many minimally coupled light scalars that can be integrated out to give these higher order operators. We show that a by product of this is the generation of quantum corrections to Newton's potential, whose observable consequences are already ruled out by solar system tests. We point out that over 7 orders of magnitude of improvement in interferometer sensitivity would be required to avoid such solar system constraints.

High Energy Physics - Theory,Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,High Energy Physics - Phenomenology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the paper attempts to solve

This paper explores how to use gravitational waves to test General Relativity (GR), especially looking for signs of deviation from General Relativity in the gravitational waves generated by merging black holes. Specifically, the paper mainly focuses on the following issues:

1. **Higher - order derivative terms in the effective field theory**:
- In the pure gravitational theory, the only way that deviations may occur is through the existence of higher - order derivative correction terms in the effective action, that is, high - power terms of the Riemann curvature tensor. The Wilson coefficients of these correction terms are restricted by observational data.
- The author reviews the known constraints on these coefficients and points out that these constraints imply a low cutoff energy of the effective theory.

2. **Constraints of causality and unitarity**:
- Starting from basic principles such as causality and unitarity, the author explores whether these higher - order derivative terms can actually be detected in principle.
- The author points out that even in some cases, the Wilson coefficients may be large enough to be detected, but from the perspective of causality and unitarity, this possibility is not clear.

3. **Contribution of light scalar particles**:
- The author considers a mechanism for generating these higher - order derivative terms, that is, generating these higher - order operators by integrating many minimally - coupled light scalar particles.
- A by - product of this mechanism is the generation of quantum corrections to the Newtonian potential, and these corrections have been excluded by solar system tests.

4. **Requirements for interferometer sensitivity**:
- The author points out that in order to avoid solar system constraints, the sensitivity of the interferometer needs to be increased by more than 7 orders of magnitude.
- Specifically, if we want to reach the LIGO/Virgo limit on the quartic Riemann operator \( \Lambda_4 \sim 1/(150 \text{km}) \), then we have already seen deviations from General Relativity in the solar system. Alternatively, in order to conform to solar system constraints, we need \( \Lambda_4 \gtrsim 1/(8.6 \text{km}) \), which is much higher than the current interferometer sensitivity.

### Conclusion

By detailed analysis of the performance of higher - order derivative terms in gravitational wave observations and the quantum corrections of these terms to the Newtonian potential, the paper draws the following conclusions:

- Current gravitational wave observations have very strict constraints on higher - order derivative terms, even exceeding the accuracy of solar system tests.
- To further verify the existence of these higher - order derivative terms, it is necessary to significantly improve the sensitivity of the interferometer, which is a huge technical challenge.
- From the perspective of causality and unitarity, the existence of these higher - order derivative terms is not inevitable and requires more theoretical and experimental research to confirm.