Abstract:In both finance and economics, quantitative models are usually studied as isolated mathematical objects --- most often defined by very strong simplifying assumptions concerning rationality, efficiency and the existence of disequilibrium adjustment mechanisms. This raises the important question of how sensitive such models might be to real-world effects that violate the assumptions. We show how the consequences of rational behavior caused by perverse incentives, as well as various irrational tendencies identified by behavioral economists, can be systematically and consistently introduced into an agent-based model for a financial asset. This generates a class of models which, in the special case where such effects are absent, reduces to geometric Brownian motion --- the usual equilibrium pricing model. Thus we are able to numerically perturb a widely-used equilibrium pricing model market and investigate its stability. The magnitude of such perturbations in real markets can be estimated and the simulations imply that this is far outside the stability region of the equilibrium solution, which is no longer observed. Indeed the price fluctuations generated by endogenous dynamics, are in good general agreement with the excess kurtosis and heteroskedasticity of actual asset prices. The methodology is presented within the context of a financial market. However, there are close links to concepts and theories from both micro- and macro-economics including rational expectations, Soros' theory of reflexivity, and Minsky's theory of financial instability.

The Elasticity of Quantitative Investment

Mispricing and the Elasticity of Quantitative Investment

Identifying Elasticities in Demand-Based Asset Pricing

Evaluating Asset Pricing Models in Absence of Arbitrage: Econometric Approach and Empirical Applications

Quantitative Fundamental Theorem of Asset Pricing

‘The importance of arbitrage free requirement in the empirical evaluation of asset pricing models

How sensitive are equilibrium pricing models to real-world distortions?

The role of arbitrage in the empirical evaluation of asset pricing models

The Statistical Limit of Arbitrage

Theory of Inverse Demand: Financial Assets

On Measuring the Economic Significance of Asset Return Predictability

The Economics of Security Analysis

Toward a Quantitative General Equilibrium Asset Pricing Model with Intangible Capital

Arbitrage and deflators in illiquid markets

Asset Prices and Risk Aversion

Infrequent Random Portfolio Decisions in an Open Economy Model

On statistical arbitrage under a conditional factor model of equity returns

Empirical Evaluation of Asset Pricing Models: Arbitrage and Pricing Errors in Contingent Claims

A Model of Anomaly Discovery

A Classical Model of Speculative Asset Price Dynamics

Robustness of mathematical models and technical analysis strategies