Smartphones with UWB: Evaluating the Accuracy and Reliability of UWB Ranging

Alexander Heinrich,Sören Krollmann,Florentin Putz,Matthias Hollick

2023-03-20

Abstract:More and more consumer devices implement the IEEE Ultra-Wide Band (UWB) standard to perform distance measurements for sensitive tasks such as keyless entry and startup of modern cars, to find lost items using coin-sized trackers, and for smart payments. While UWB promises the ability to perform time-of-flight centimeter-accurate distance measurements between two devices, the accuracy and reliability of the implementation in up-to-date consumer devices have not been evaluated so far. In this paper, we present the first evaluation of UWB smartphones from Apple, Google, and Samsung, focusing on accuracy and reliability in passive keyless entry and smart home automation scenarios. To perform the measurements for our analysis, we build a custom-designed testbed based on a Gimbal-based platform for Wireless Evaluation (GWEn), which allows us to create reproducible measurements. All our results, including all measurement data and a manual to reconstruct a GWEn are published online. We find that the evaluated devices can measure the distance with an error of less than 20cm, but fail in producing reliable measurements in all scenarios. Finally, we give recommendations on how to handle measurement results when implementing a passive keyless entry system.

Cryptography and Security,Performance

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the accuracy and reliability of distance measurement using Ultra-Wide Band (UWB) technology in modern smartphones. Specifically, the study focuses on the following aspects:

1. **Research Background**: With the development of UWB technology, an increasing number of consumer electronic devices are integrating UWB functionality for precise distance measurement. These measurements are used in various application scenarios, such as keyless car entry, finding lost items, and smart payments.

2. **Research Objective**: Currently, there is no public evaluation of the accuracy and reliability of UWB implementations in the latest consumer devices. Therefore, this paper aims to assess the distance measurement performance of UWB smartphones from Apple, Google, and Samsung, with particular attention to the performance in Passive Keyless Entry (PKE) and smart home automation scenarios.

3. **Experimental Method**: To conduct these measurements, the researchers built a custom test platform called GWEn (Gyroscope-based Wireless Evaluation platform). This platform allows for repeatable position adjustments of the Device Under Test (DUT) to obtain reliable data.

4. **Main Findings**:
- UWB measurements in smartphones are not sufficiently reliable due to the high directionality of the built-in antennas.
- Despite the directionality issue, the average error is less than 21 centimeters, which is sufficient to meet the requirements of PKE systems.
- There are outliers within a range of a few meters that affect overall accuracy; however, the standard deviation is usually less than 25 centimeters.
- The UWB and Android OS software integration in Google Pixel smartphones is unstable, whereas Samsung devices exhibit better stability.

5. **Contributions**: The authors conducted the first measurements of UWB smartphones from Apple, Samsung, and Google and designed a rotatable 3D-printed test bed, GWEn, to comprehensively evaluate the accuracy and reliability of UWB distance measurement. Additionally, they provided recommendations for implementing secure keyless entry systems and published all measurement data and GWEn's construction guidelines online.

In summary, through detailed experiments and analysis, the paper reveals the advantages and limitations of current UWB smartphones in practical applications and provides valuable insights for future technological improvements.