Abstract:In this paper, we propose a multi-RREH (Remote Renewable Energy Hub) based optimization framework. This framework allows a valorization of CO2 using carbon capture technologies. This valorization is grounded on the idea that CO2 gathered from the atmosphere or post combustion can be combined with hydrogen to produce synthetic methane. The hydrogen is obtained from water electrolysis using renewable energy (RE). Such renewable energy is generated in RREHs, which are locations where RE is cheap and abundant (e.g., solar PV in the Sahara Desert, or wind in Greenland). We instantiate our framework on a case study focusing on Belgium and 2 RREHs, and we conduct a techno-economic analysis. This analysis highlights the key role played by the cost of the two main carbon capture technologies: Post Combustion Carbon Capture (PCCC) and Direct Air Capture (DAC). In addition, we use our framework to derive a carbon price threshold above which carbon capture technologies may start playing a pivotal role in the decarbonation process of our industries. For example, this price threshold may give relevant information for calibrating the EU Emission Trading System so as to trigger the emergence of the multi-RREH.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to realize the valorization of carbon dioxide (CO2) within the framework of Multi - Remote Renewable Energy Hubs (Multi - RREH). Specifically, the paper explores how to collect CO2 through carbon capture technologies (including Post - Combustion Carbon Capture (PCCC) and Direct Air Capture (DAC)), and combine it with green hydrogen produced through hydrolysis to produce synthetic methane. This process aims to utilize regions with abundant and low - cost renewable energy (such as solar energy in the Sahara Desert or wind energy in Greenland), and evaluate the economic and technical feasibility of such a system through an optimization model.
### Core Problems of the Paper
1. **CO2 Valorization**: The paper proposes a multi - RREH optimization framework, which combines CO2 in the atmosphere or post - combustion CO2 with green hydrogen through carbon capture technologies to produce synthetic methane.
2. **Economic and Technical Feasibility**: Through a case study, evaluate the economic and technical feasibility of implementing this system in Belgium and its two RREHs (located in Algeria and Greenland).
3. **Carbon Price Threshold**: Determine a carbon price threshold, which enables carbon capture technologies to play a key role in the industrial decarbonization process. This helps to calibrate the EU Emissions Trading System (EU ETS) to promote the development of multi - RREH.
### Main Research Contents
- **Optimization Framework**: Propose a multi - RREH optimization framework for evaluating the economic and technical feasibility of CO2 capture and utilization.
- **Technology Selection**: Compare the costs and benefits of two carbon capture technologies, PCCC and DAC.
- **Economic Analysis**: Through a linear programming model, evaluate the total costs in different scenarios, including energy demand, CO2 capture and transportation, synthetic methane production, etc.
- **Carbon Price Threshold**: Obtain a carbon price threshold through the model, which makes carbon capture technologies economically viable.
### Key Conclusions
- **Cost Reduction**: In the reference scenario, using PCCC instead of only using DAC can significantly reduce the total cost of the system, by approximately 9.2%.
- **Carbon Price Threshold**: A carbon price threshold has been determined, which makes carbon capture technologies economically viable in the industrial decarbonization process. For example, in the Belgium and RREHs system, when the carbon price reaches 162.77 euros/ton, these emissions can be avoided and the export and storage of CO2 can be activated.
- **Technical Advantage**: PCCC has a higher concentration of CO2 in the flue gas production, so it is usually more economical than DAC, even if the DAC technology has been improved.
### Methodology
- **Linear Programming Model**: Model in GBOML language, optimize multi - energy systems through linear programming, considering the constraints of nodes and hyper - edges.
- **Case Study**: Take Belgium and its two RREHs (Algeria and Greenland) as examples to evaluate the economic and technical feasibility of the system.
### Formula Examples
- **CAPEX Calculation**:
\[
\zeta_n=\frac{\text{CAPEX}_n\times w}{1-(1 + w)^{-L_n}}
\]
where \(\zeta_n\) represents the annualized investment cost of technology \(n\), \(\text{CAPEX}_n\) is the initial capital expenditure, \(w\) is the weighted average cost of capital (WACC), and \(L_n\) is the lifespan of technology \(n\).
- **Net CO2 Emission Ceiling**:
\[
\sum_{t\in T}\left(\sum_{a\in A}q^{\text{co2}}_{a,t}-\sum_{c\in C}q^{\text{co2}}_{c,t}\right)\leq\kappa_{\text{co2}}\nu
\]
where \(A\) and \(C\) respectively represent the sets of technologies that release CO2 into the atmosphere and those that capture CO2 from the atmosphere, \(\kappa_{\text{co2}}\) is the annual CO2 emission ceiling (thousand tons/year), and \(\nu\) is the number of years in the optimization time range.
Through these methods and models, the paper provides an economically and technically feasible solution for the valorization of CO2.