Abstract:This paper is a critical study of non-standard Maxwellian electrodynamics. It explores two important topics: the inclusion of both magnetic and electric charge to produce what it calls Extended Electrodynamics, and the existence of a symmetry called Dyality Invariance that exchanges electric and magnetic quantities. First, the paper summarizes Extended Electrodynamics, including potentials, gauge transformations, and a new proof of the extended electrodynamic Poynting theorem. A formal Lagrangian derivation of the extended Maxwell equations is also given, but its value in fundamental studies is questioned. The paper then defines Dyality Invariance (form invariance under the so-called Dyality Transformation that exchanges electric and magnetic quantities) and shows it to be a valid symmetry if and only if electrodynamics is given the extended form. The paper suggests that the complete Maxwellian electrodynamics is extended electrodynamics with its dyality invariance. But dyality can be interpreted either actively or passively. Since magnetic charge has not been observed experimentally, the active interpretation is ruled out. But a passive interpretation can be used to avoid writing magnetic source and potential terms explicitly. The paper also refutes the idea that dyality invariance would permit a magnetic charge to be transformed away even if one existed. If nonzero magnetic charge exists, then experimental evidence for its existence cannot be hidden by a dyality transformation.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address two main issues:
1. **Extended Maxwell Electrodynamics**: The paper explores how to incorporate both magnetic and electric charges into the Maxwell equations to form the so-called "Extended Electrodynamics." This includes introducing new potential functions, gauge transformations, and a new proof of the extended Poynting theorem.
2. **Duality Invariance**: The paper defines a symmetry called "duality transformation," which remains invariant when electric and magnetic quantities are exchanged. The paper points out that this symmetry only holds in extended electrodynamics and not in standard electrodynamics.
### Specific Issues and Solutions
- **Extended Electrodynamics**:
- Introduced the magnetic charge density four-vector \( L^\beta \) as the source of the dual field tensor \( G^{\alpha\beta} \).
- Derived the extended Maxwell equations:
\[
\partial_\alpha F^{\alpha\beta} = -\frac{1}{c} J^\beta, \quad \partial_\alpha G^{\alpha\beta} = -\frac{1}{c} L^\beta
\]
- Proved the extended Poynting theorem and discussed the form of the energy-momentum tensor \( T^{\alpha\beta} \).
- **Duality Invariance**:
- Defined the duality transformation:
\[
(E', B') = (B, -E), \quad (J', L') = (L, -J), \quad (A', N') = (N, -A)
\]
- Proved that under duality transformation, the extended electrodynamics equations remain invariant, whereas standard electrodynamics does not possess this symmetry in the presence of sources.
### Main Contributions of the Paper
- **Theoretical Framework**: Proposed an extended electrodynamics framework that includes both magnetic and electric charges, providing a new perspective for studying electromagnetic phenomena.
- **Symmetry Analysis**: By introducing duality invariance, revealed deep symmetries in electrodynamics, providing a theoretical foundation for further research.
- **Experimental Significance**: Although magnetic charges have not been observed, the paper discusses both active and passive interpretations of duality transformations, providing theoretical preparation for the potential future discovery of magnetic charges.
### Conclusion
By extending the Maxwell equations and introducing duality invariance, the paper provides a new theoretical framework for the study of electrodynamics. Although there is currently no experimental evidence supporting the existence of magnetic charges, this theoretical framework offers important references for future experimental and theoretical research.