Abstract:Semiclassical electrodynamics is an appealing approach for studying light-matter interactions, especially for realistic molecular systems. However, there is no unique semiclassical scheme. On the one hand, intermolecular interactions can be described instantaneously by static two-body interactions connecting different molecules plus a classical transverse E-field; we will call this Hamiltonian #I. On the other hand, intermolecular interactions can also be described as effects that are mediated exclusively through a classical one-body E-field without any quantum effects at all (assuming we ignore electronic exchange); we will call this Hamiltonian #II. Moreover, one can also mix these two Hamiltonians into a third, hybrid Hamiltonian, which preserves quantum electron-electron correlations for lower excitations but describes higher excitations in a mean-field way. To investigate which semiclassical scheme is most reliable for practical use, here we study the real-time dynamics of a pair of identical two-level systems (TLSs) undergoing either resonance energy transfer (RET) or collectively driven dynamics. While all approaches perform reasonably well when there is no strong external excitation, we find that no single approach is perfect for all conditions. Each method has its own distinct problems: Hamiltonian #I performs best for RET but behaves in a complicated manner for driven dynamics. Hamiltonian #II is always stable, but obviously fails for RET at short distances. One key finding is that, under externally driving, a full configuration interaction description of Hamiltonian #I strongly overestimates the long-time electronic energy, highlighting the not obvious fact that, if one plans to merge quantum molecules with classical light, a full, exact treatment of electron-electron correlations can actually lead to worse results than a simple mean-field treatment.

Sum rules for light-dressed matter

Quantum Phase Transition of Light in the Dissipative Rabi-Hubbard Lattice: A Dressed-Master-equation Perspective

Characterizing Strong Light-Atom Interaction by a Self-Consistent Solution to Maxwell-Schrödinger Equations

Charge and Current Sum Rules in Quantum Media Coupled to Radiation II

Sum rules for the Gravitational Form Factors using light-front dressed quark state

Exploring the equivalence of causality-based and quantum mechanics-based sum rules for harmonic generation in nonlinear optical materials

Understanding the Nature of Mean-Field Semiclassical Light-Matter Dynamics: An Investigation of Energy Transfer, Electron-Electron Correlations, External Driving and Long-Time Detailed Balance

f-Sum Rules for Dissipative Systems

From Bjorken To Drell-Hearn-Gerasimov Sum Rules

Structure Function Sum rules for Systems with Large Scattering Lengths

WHAT ARE THESE SUM RULES GOOD FOR

Sum rules for hadronic contributions to low-energy light-by-light scattering

Is the low-energy optical absorption in correlated insulators controlled by quantum geometry?

Light-matter quantum dynamics of complex laser-driven systems

A Comparison of Different Classical, Semiclassical and Quantum Treatments of Light-Matter Interactions: Understanding Energy Conservation

Gravity-Matter Sum Rules in models with a single extra-dimension

Artificial light and quantum order in systems of screened dipoles

Sum rule for transport in a Luttinger liquid with long range interaction in the presence of an impurity

Comparison of Different Classical, Semiclassical, and Quantum Treatments of Light-Matter Interactions: Understanding Energy Conservation

Laplace Sum Rules in Quantum ChromoDynamics

QED of Bernabéu-Tarrach sum rule for electric polarizability and its implication for the Lamb shift