Artificial light and quantum order in systems of screened dipoles

Xiao-Gang Wen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.68.115413

2003-04-14

Abstract:The origin of light is a unsolved mystery in nature. Recently, it was suggested that light may originate from a new kind of order - quantum order. To test this idea in experiments, we study systems of screened magnetic/electric dipoles in 2D and 3D lattices. We show that our models contain an artificial light -- a photon-like collective excitation. We discuss how to design realistic devices that realize our models. We show that the ``speed of light'' and the ``fine structure constant'' of the artificial light can be tuned in our models. The properties of artificial atoms (bound states of pairs of artificial charges) are also discussed. The existence of artificial light (as well as artificial electron) in condensed matter systems suggests that elementary particles, such as light and electron, may not be elementary. They may be collective excitations of quantum order in our vacuum. Our models further suggest that a gauge theory is a string-net theory in disguise. Light is a fluctuation of nets of large closed strings and charge is the end of open strings.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,High Energy Physics - Theory

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore whether the origin of light (i.e., electromagnetic waves) can be attributed to a new quantum order. Specifically, the author proposes a hypothesis: light may be a collective excitation phenomenon generated by the quantum order in vacuum. To verify this hypothesis, the author studied the models of shielded dipole systems in two - dimensional and three - dimensional lattices and demonstrated the existence of collective excitations similar to photons - artificial light - in these models.

### Main problems and goals of the paper

1. **Origin of light**:
- Traditionally, light is regarded as a fundamental particle (such as a photon), but this paper presents a new view: light may not be a fundamental particle but a collective excitation generated by the quantum order in vacuum.
- Can the origin of light be explained as a manifestation of quantum order?

2. **Existence of artificial light**:
- Study shielded magnetic/electric dipole systems to verify whether there are collective excitations similar to photons (i.e., artificial light).
- Design practical devices to implement these models and show how to adjust the "speed of light" and the "fine - structure constant".

3. **Quantum order and gauge theory**:
- Explore the relationship between quantum order and gauge theory, and propose that gauge theory is actually a disguise of string - net theory.
- String - net theory holds that light is the fluctuation of string - nets, and electric charge is the end point of an open string or a node of a string - net.

### Key hypotheses and models

- **Shielded dipole system**: By studying shielded magnetic/electric dipole systems in two - dimensional and three - dimensional lattices, show the collective excitation phenomena existing in these systems.
- **Properties of artificial light**: Discuss the properties of artificial light, including the adjustability of its "speed of light" and "fine - structure constant".
- **Artificial atom**: Discuss the properties of the bound state (i.e., artificial atom) composed of a pair of artificial charges.

### Experimental verification

- Propose methods for designing practical devices to realize the artificial light phenomena observed in these models.
- Verify these models through experiments, showing that photons and electrons can exist as collective excitations in specific lattice boson models, thus proving that they do not necessarily have to be fundamental particles.

### Conclusion

Through these studies, the author hopes to deepen our understanding of the phases of matter, especially to discover a new quantum order that can generate and protect light. This will not only help to understand the nature of light but may also reveal that other fundamental particles (such as electrons) may not be fundamental particles either but collective excitations of some quantum order.

### Representation of mathematical formulas

Some key formulas involved in the paper are represented in Markdown format as follows:

- **Hamiltonian**:
\[
H = U \sum_i \left( \sum_\alpha \sigma_z^{\langle i, i+\alpha \rangle} S_z^{\langle i, i+\alpha \rangle} \right)^2 + J \sum_I (S_z^I)^2 - \frac{1}{S^2} \sum_{\langle IJ \rangle} \sigma_z^I \sigma_z^J \left( t S_+^I S_-^J + t' S_+^I S_+^J e^{i2\phi_{IJ}} + h.c. \right)
\]

- **String operator**:
\[
U(C) = \prod_{\langle ij \rangle} S_\eta^{\langle ij \rangle} \sigma_z^{\langle ij \rangle}
\]

- **Gauge transformation**:
\[
U(\phi_i) = e^{i \sum_i (\eta_i \phi_i \sum_\alpha \sigma_z^{\langle i, i+\alpha \rangle} S_z^{\langle i, i+\alpha \rangle})}
\]

- **Effective Lagrangian**:
\[
L = \frac{1}{4J} \sum_i \left( \dot{a}_{i,i+1} \right)