Six equations in search of a finite-fold-ness proof

Domenico Cantone,Luca Cuzziol,Eugenio G. Omodeo

2024-10-01

Abstract:By following the same construction pattern which Martin Davis proposed in a 1968 paper of his, we have obtained six quaternary quartic Diophantine equations that candidate as `rule-them-all' equations: proving that one of them has only a finite number of integer solutions would suffice to ensure that each recursively enumerable set admits a finite-fold polynomial Diophantine representation.

Number Theory,Logic

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problem does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to explore six specific quaternary quartic Diophantine equations and whether these equations have a finite number of integer solutions. Specifically, if it can be proven that any one of these equations has only a finite number of integer solutions, then it will mean that every recursively enumerable (r.e.) set allows a finite - fold polynomial Diophantine representation. This representation is of great significance for the study of Hilbert's 10th problem.

### Specific problem description

The key problem mentioned in the paper is: Does there exist a quaternary quartic Diophantine equation that has only a finite number of integer solutions? This problem is important because it is closely related to the following two aspects:

1. **Representation of recursively enumerable sets**:
If a certain quaternary quartic Diophantine equation has only a finite number of integer solutions, then every recursively enumerable set can be represented by a finite - fold polynomial Diophantine equation. This means that for any partial computable function \( f(\vec{a}) \) from \( \mathbb{N}^m \) to \( \mathbb{N} \), there exists a multivariate polynomial \( D\in\mathbb{Z}[a_1,\cdots,a_m,x_1,\cdots,x_k] \) such that for each \( \vec{a}\in\mathbb{N}^m \), the following conditions are satisfied:
- \( f(\vec{a}) \) has a value if and only if there exists \( \vec{x}\in\mathbb{N}^k \) such that \( D(\vec{a},\vec{x}) = 0 \);
- There exists \( b\in\mathbb{N} \) such that for all \( \vec{x}\in\mathbb{N}^k \), if \( D(\vec{a},\vec{x}) = 0 \), then \( b > \sum\vec{x} \).

2. **Representation of exponential growth relationships**:
If one of the above equations indeed has only a finite number of solutions, then the corresponding binary relation \( J_d \) will be able to be represented by a polynomial Diophantine equation. Specifically, for some \( d\in\{2,7\} \) or \( d\in\{3,11,19,43\} \), the relation \( J_d(p,q) \) is defined as:
- When \( d\in\{2,7\} \): \( J_d(p,q)\Leftrightarrow\exists\ell > 4[q = y_{2^\ell}(d)\&p|q\&p\geq 2^{\ell + 1}] \)
- When \( d\in\{3,11,19,43\} \): \( J_d(p,q)\Leftrightarrow\exists\ell > 5[q = y_{2^{2\ell+1}}(d)\&p|q\&p\geq 2^{2\ell+2}] \)

### Research background

The paper continues a construction pattern proposed by Martin Davis in 1968 and generates six quaternary quartic Diophantine equations. These equations are associated with Pell's equation \( x^2 - dy^2 = 1 \). Davis once proposed that if it can be proven that a certain specific quaternary quartic equation (such as the one related to \( d = 7 \)) has only a finite number of solutions, then the undecidability of Hilbert's 10th problem can be deduced. However, Shanks and Wagstaff conjectured that this equation actually has an infinite number of solutions.