Dilemma in All-optical Characterization of Single-layer NiI2 Multiferroics

Yucheng Jiang,Yangliu Wu,Jinlei Zhang,Jingxuan Wei,Bo Peng,Cheng-Wei Qiu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-023-06107-3

2023-06-21

Abstract:Matters Arising in Nature on "Evidence for a single layer van der Waals multiferroic". The search for two dimensional multiferroic materials is an exciting yet challenging endeavor. Recently, Song reported the exciting discovery of type II multiferroic order in an antiferromagnetic (AFM) NiI2 single layer and concluded the ferroelectric (FE) polarization induced by a helical magnetic order1. Their finding was presented from all optical experimental evidence, based on the methods of second harmonic generation (SHG) and linear dichroism (LD). However, the all optical characterizations cannot serve as unanimous evidence of the FE existence, particularly in conjunction with magnetic orders in a single layer NiI2 multiferroic. We have designed and built a Magneto-Optical-Electric Joint-measurement Scanning Imaging system (MOEJSI) for identification of two-dimensional vdW multiferroic.

Materials Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The key problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether the optical characterization of single - layer NiI₂ multiferroic materials can reliably prove that it has the co - existence characteristics of ferroelectricity and magnetic order. Specifically, the paper questions the conclusions drawn only by all - optical methods (such as second - harmonic generation (SHG) and linear dichroism (LD)) in previous studies, believing that these methods may not be able to distinguish the signals caused by ferroelectric polarization and magnetic order.

### Main problems:
1. **Reliability of single all - optical characterization**: The paper points out that it is unreliable to only rely on all - optical methods such as SHG and LD to characterize the multiferroic properties of single - layer NiI₂. These methods may be affected by magnetic order, leading to misjudgment.
2. **Confusion between magnetic order and ferroelectricity**: In single - layer or multi - layer materials, magnetic order can break spatial inversion symmetry or time - reversal symmetry, thus generating SHG and LD signals. This makes these signals not necessarily directly reflect the existence of ferroelectric polarization.
3. **Insufficient experimental data**: The experimental data in the original study is not sufficient to support its conclusions, especially the lack of control experiments on SHG or LD domains under applied electric and magnetic fields, and it is unable to clearly distinguish the sources of optical signals.
4. **Need for more direct measurement means**: In order to confirm the multiferroic properties of single - layer NiI₂, more direct measurement methods are required, such as piezoresponse force microscopy (PFM), to verify the existence of ferroelectric domains and compare them with SHG domains.

### Main arguments of the paper:
- SHG and LD signals can be generated not only by ferroelectric polarization, but also by magnetic order.
- A single all - optical method is not sufficient to prove the multiferroic properties of single - layer NiI₂.
- It is necessary to combine more direct electrical and magnetic measurement means to reliably determine whether single - layer NiI₂ is a multiferroic material.

Therefore, this paper aims to emphasize the limitations of existing evidence and calls for more comprehensive and direct experimental verification to ensure the correct understanding of the multiferroic properties of single - layer NiI₂.