Ferroelastic toughening: can it solve the mechanics challenges of solid electrolytes?

Anton Van der Ven,Robert M. McMeeking,Raphaële J. Clément,Krishna Garikipati
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cossms.2023.101056
2023-02-19
Abstract:The most promising solid electrolytes for all-solid-state Li batteries are oxide and sulfide ceramics. Current ceramic solid electrolytes are brittle and lack the toughness to withstand the mechanical stresses of repeated charge and discharge cycles. Solid electrolytes are susceptible to crack propagation due to dendrite growth from Li metal anodes and to debonding processes at the cathode/electrolyte interface due to cyclic variations in the cathode lattice parameters. In this perspective, we argue that solutions to the mechanics challenges of all-solid-state batteries can be borrowed from the aerospace industry, which successfully overcame similar hurdles in the development of thermal barrier coatings of superalloy turbine blades. Their solution was to exploit ferroelastic and transformation toughening mechanisms to develop ceramics that can withstand cyclic stresses due to large variations in temperature. This perspective describes fundamental materials design principles with which to search for solid electrolytes that are ferroelastically toughened.
Materials Science
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily explores the mechanical performance challenges faced by solid electrolyte materials in all-solid-state batteries and proposes a solution inspired by the thermal barrier coating technology in the aerospace industry—using the Ferroelastic toughening mechanism to improve the mechanical performance of solid electrolytes. ### Problems the Paper Aims to Address 1. **Enhancing the Commercial Viability of All-Solid-State Batteries**: Although solid electrolytes have great potential, their brittleness and inability to withstand mechanical stress during charge and discharge cycles limit their commercial application. Therefore, the paper aims to find ways to improve the toughness of solid electrolytes to address these challenges. 2. **Solving Interface Compatibility Issues**: During charge and discharge processes, the lithium concentration in the cathode material changes significantly, leading to changes in lattice parameters. This causes a mismatch between the solid electrolyte layer and the electrode, resulting in mechanical degradation, loss of coherence, and ionic contact. The paper proposes a method to maintain this coherence. 3. **Suppressing Lithium Dendrite Growth**: Lithium dendrites can penetrate solid electrolytes, causing short circuits. The paper explores how to prevent this process by increasing the toughness of solid electrolytes. ### Solution The paper draws on the successful experience of thermal barrier coatings in the aerospace industry, particularly the Ferroelastic and transformation toughening mechanisms of yttria-stabilized zirconia (YSZ) coatings, and proposes applying similar principles to the design of solid electrolyte materials. Specifically, by designing solid electrolyte materials with highly twinned structures, microstructures that can resist crack propagation can be formed within the material, thereby improving overall mechanical toughness. ### Implementation Approach - **Structural Phase Transformation**: Generate twinned microstructures with multiple orientation variants through specific types of structural phase transformations (e.g., tetragonal to cubic transformation). - **Ferroelastic Toughening Mechanism**: When subjected to external forces, favorably oriented variants will expand through twin boundary migration, achieving macroscopic deformation. This helps alleviate periodic stress fluctuations at the electrode-electrolyte interface and suppress crack propagation. ### Material Requirements To achieve the above mechanisms, the paper also discusses the required material properties, including the ability to form twin boundaries with high mobility. Additionally, several possible material systems are proposed, such as compounds based on perovskite structures, which have the potential to produce the required microstructures through weak martensitic transformations. In summary, the main goal of the paper is to overcome the mechanical performance challenges of solid electrolyte materials in all-solid-state batteries by introducing the Ferroelastic toughening mechanism.