Strongly superadiabatic and stratified limits of compressible convection

John Panickacheril John,Jörg Schumacher
2023-10-04
Abstract:Fully compressible turbulent convection beyond the Oberbeck-Boussinesq limit and anelastic regime is studied in three-dimensional numerical simulations. Superadiabaticity $\epsilon$ and dissipation number $D$, which measures the strength of stratification of adiabatic equilibria, cause two limits of compressible convection -- nearly top-down-symmetric, strongly superadiabatic and highly top-down-asymmetric, strongly stratified convection. Highest turbulent Mach numbers $M_t$ follow for a symmetric blend of these two limits which we term the fully compressible case. Particularly, the strongly stratified convection case leads to a fluctuation-reduced top layer in the convection zone, a strongly reduced global heat transfer, and differing boundary layer dynamics between top and bottom. We detect this asymmetry for growing dissipation number $D$ also in the phase plane which is spanned by the turbulent Mach number $M_t$ and the dilatation parameter $\delta$ which relates the dilatational velocity fluctuations to the solenoidal ones. A detailed analysis of the different transport currents in the fully compressible energy budget relates the low-$D$ convection cases to the standard definition of the dimensionless Nusselt number in the Oberbeck-Boussinesq limit.
Fluid Dynamics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to study fully compressible turbulent convection beyond the Oberbeck - Boussinesq limit and in the anelastic regime. Specifically, the author explores the effects of super - adiabaticity \(\epsilon\) and dissipation number \(D\) on two compressible convection limits, namely, the strongly superadiabatic convection (SAC) which is almost vertically symmetric, and the strongly stratified convection (SSC) which is highly vertically asymmetric, through three - dimensional numerical simulations. It is found that in the mixed state of these two limits (referred to as fully compressible convection, FCC), the highest turbulent Mach number \(M_t\) can be observed. ### Main problems addressed in the paper: 1. **Explore the influence of super - adiabaticity and stratification intensity**: The paper studies the influence of super - adiabaticity \(\epsilon\) and dissipation number \(D\) on compressible convection through numerical simulations. These two parameters measure the super - adiabatic degree and stratification intensity of the convection system respectively. 2. **Analyze the characteristics under different convection limits**: The paper analyzes in detail the turbulent characteristics of the convection system under the two limits of strongly superadiabatic convection (SAC) and strongly stratified convection (SSC), including the turbulent Mach number \(M_t\), temperature distribution, velocity distribution, etc. 3. **Explore the characteristics of fully compressible convection**: The paper pays special attention to the maximum turbulent Mach number \(M_t\) and other related characteristics exhibited by the convection system in the mixed state of SAC and SSC (i.e., FCC). 4. **Compare the energy transfer under different convection limits**: The paper compares the heat transfer and momentum transfer efficiencies in various convection situations by conducting a detailed analysis of the energy equation budgets under different convection limits. ### Main findings: - **Characteristics of SAC and SSC**: SAC is characterized by cold downdrafts that penetrate deeply into the center of the convective layer, resulting in a slight shift in the temperature distribution; while SSC forms a sub - layer with weakened turbulence at the top, leading to a significant reduction in global heat transfer. - **Maximum turbulent Mach number in FCC**: In the mixed state of SAC and SSC (FCC), the highest turbulent Mach number \(M_t\) can be observed, indicating that the convection is the most intense in the FCC state. - **Differences in boundary - layer dynamics**: In the SSC case, there are significant differences in the boundary - layer dynamics at the top and bottom, especially the formation of a sub - layer with weakened turbulence at the top. ### Formula summary: - **Super - adiabaticity \(\epsilon\)**: \[ \epsilon=\frac{\bar{T}_{\text{top}} - T_{\text{top}}}{T_{\text{bot}}} \] - **Dissipation number \(D\)**: \[ D = \frac{gH}{C_p T_{\text{bot}}}=\frac{T_{\text{bot}}-\bar{T}_{\text{top}}}{T_{\text{bot}}} \] - **Free - fall Mach number \(M_f\)**: \[ M_f=\frac{U_f}{c_s}=\sqrt{\frac{\epsilon D}{\gamma - 1}} \] - **Turbulent Mach number \(M_t\)**: \[ M_t(z)=\frac{u'(z)}{\sqrt{\gamma R\langle T(z)\rangle_{A,t}}} \] - **Expansion parameter \(\delta\)**: \[ \delta(z)=\sqrt{\frac{\langle\epsilon_d(z)\rangle_{A,t}}{\langle\epsilon_s(