Theoretical study of phonon-mediated superconductivity beyond Migdal-Eliashberg approximation and Coulomb pseudopotential

Jie Huang,Zhao-Kun Yang,Xiao-Yin Pan,Guo-Zhu Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.108.144507

2023-10-23

Abstract:In previous theoretical studies of phonon-mediated superconductors, the electron-phonon coupling is treated by solving the Migdal-Eliashberg equations under the bare vertex approximation, whereas the effect of Coulomb repulsion is incorporated by introducing one single pseudopotential parameter. These two approximations become unreliable in low carrier-density superconductors in which the vertex corrections are not small and the Coulomb interaction is poorly screened. Here, we shall go beyond these two approximations and employ the Dyson-Schwinger equation approach to handle the interplay of electron-phonon interaction and Coulomb interaction in a self-consistent way. We first derive the exact Dyson-Schwinger integral equation of the full electron propagator. Such an equation contains several unknown single-particle propagators and fermion-boson vertex functions, and thus seems to be intractable. To solve this difficulty, we further derive a number of identities satisfied by all the relevant propagators and vertex functions and then use these identities to show that the exact Dyson-Schwinger equation of electron propagator is actually self-closed. This self-closed equation takes into account not only all the vertex corrections, but also the mutual influence between electron-phonon interaction and Coulomb interaction. Solving it by using proper numerical methods leads to the superconducting temperature $T_{c}$ and other quantities. As an application of the approach, we compute the $T_{c}$ of the interfacial superconductivity realized in the one-unit-cell FeSe/SrTiO$_{3}$ system. We find that $T_{c}$ can be strongly influenced by the vertex corrections and the competition between phonon-mediated attraction and Coulomb repulsion.

Superconductivity,Strongly Correlated Electrons

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to solve the problem of the failure of the traditional treatment methods (Migdal - Eliashberg theory and Coulomb pseudopotential method) of electron - phonon interaction (EPI) and Coulomb interaction in superconductors with low carrier density. Specifically:

1. **Limitations of traditional methods**:
- In the traditional Migdal - Eliashberg theory, the electron - phonon coupling is treated by solving the Migdal - Eliashberg equation, while the Coulomb repulsion is approximately considered by introducing a single pseudopotential parameter.
- These methods are reliable in the study of superconducting transitions in normal metals because Migdal's theorem ensures that vertex corrections can be neglected and the Coulomb interaction is well - screened.
- However, in superconductors with low carrier density, these conditions no longer hold. Migdal's theorem fails, and the Coulomb interaction is not effectively screened, leading to doubts about the reliability of traditional methods.

2. **Objectives of the paper**:
- The paper aims to go beyond the traditional Migdal - Eliashberg theory and Coulomb pseudopotential method and propose a new method to deal with the mutual influence of electron - phonon interaction and Coulomb interaction.
- The specific method is to use the Dyson - Schwinger equation (DS equation) to deal with these interactions and derive a series of exact identities to make the DS equation self - closed so that it can be solved numerically.

3. **Specific methods**:
- The paper first derives the exact Dyson - Schwinger integral equation for the full - electron propagator, which contains multiple unknown single - particle propagators and fermion - boson vertex functions.
- To overcome the difficulties caused by these unknowns, the paper further derives some identities that make the exact Dyson - Schwinger equation for the electron propagator self - closed.
- The self - closed equation takes into account not only all vertex corrections but also the mutual influence between electron - phonon interaction and Coulomb interaction.

4. **Application examples**:
- As an application of the method, the paper calculates the interface superconducting critical temperature Tc in the one - unit - layer FeSe/SrTiO₃ system.
- The results show that vertex corrections and the competition between electron - phonon attraction and Coulomb repulsion have a significant impact on Tc.

In summary, by proposing a new theoretical framework, this paper solves the problem of the failure of traditional methods in superconductors with low carrier density and provides a new tool for more accurate research on such superconductors.