Abstract:PurposeWe observe a methodological gap for assessing impacts within the Area of Protection (AoP) Natural Resources in LCA with regard to concerns about the accessibility to raw materials. Adding criticality considerations as a complement to environmental LCA addresses abiotic resources accessibility. We present a study that integrates and applies an improved GeoPolRisk midpoint and the published GeoPolEndpoint methods as valuable enhancements to the current pool of available impact methods in LCA.MethodsGeoPolEndpoint, an extension of the GeoPolRisk method, was designed to quantify the impacts of the use of raw materials from a criticality perspective at the endpoint level. We present an integrated characterization model including an improved midpoint method, which truly takes into account the mass flow extracted for a product, to operationalize the use of these methods at both midpoint and endpoint level within LCIA. We study the impacts of four relevant metals (Al, Co, Cu, and Ni) in the life cycle of lithium-ion batteries (LIB) for the years 2015 to 2017 from the perspective of the EU. Inventory data are based on previously published studies with a detailed bill of materials for two types of LIB. As part of an integrated assessment, results at midpoint and endpoint levels were compared to other impact categories within the context of an attributional LCA.Results and discussionFrom the analyzed raw materials, copper and nickel contribute significantly to environmental impacts; however, cobalt has a high geopolitical supply risk indicator and higher contribution at the GeoPolEndpoint despite its relatively low contribution to the environmental footprint of LIB. Results show the importance of specific raw materials present in small quantities, but with a high contribution when applying a criticality lens as a complement to LCA. The new method has the potential to be operationalized in LCA studies and to provide new insights on supply risk during product development.ConclusionsImpacts of the use of raw materials deemed critical are not only restricted to an environmental dimension; we can model socio-economic impacts through a criticality perspective. The GeoPolRisk and GeoPolEndpoint methods allow the integration of a supply risk perspective into LCA studies. With the introduction and development of new technologies, the evaluation of raw material criticality in LCA becomes an important complement to environmental indicators. This case study provides a baseline for future applications of the method to products and technologies that require the use of critical raw materials throughout their life cycle.

Global Competition in the Lithium-Ion Battery Supply Chain: A Novel Perspective for Criticality Analysis

Surplus energy utilization of spent lithium-ion batteries for high-profit organolithiums

High Concentration from Resources to Market Heightens Risk for Power Lithium-Ion Battery Supply Chains Globally

Lithium Supply Chain Optimization: A Global Analysis of Critical Minerals for Batteries

Exploring the Potential for Improving Material Utilization Efficiency to Secure Lithium Supply for China's Battery Supply Chain

Features of critical resource trade networks of lithium-ion batteries

Supply Risks of Lithium-Ion Battery Materials: an Entire Supply Chain Estimation

A raw material criticality and environmental impact assessment of state-of-the-art and post-lithium-ion cathode technologies

Global Lithium Flow 1994-2015: Implications for Improving Resource Efficiency and Security

An Overview of Global Power Lithium-Ion Batteries and Associated Critical Metal Recycling.

Dynamic material flow analysis of critical metals for lithium-ion battery system in China from 2000–2018

China's lithium supply chains: Network evolution and resilience assessment

Tracing Global Lithium Flow: A Trade-Linked Material Flow Analysis

Assessment of lithium criticality in the global energy transition and addressing policy gaps in transportation

Assessing the supply risk of geopolitics on critical minerals for energy storage technology in China

Supply and demand prospect of global lithium resources and some suggestions

Closing the Loop on LIB Waste: A Comparison of the Current Challenges and Opportunities for the U.S. and Australia towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Cobalt‐Free Cathode Materials: Families and their Prospects

Multiplex Characteristics and Vulnerability Assessment of the Global Electric Vehicle Lithium-Ion Battery Supply Chain Network: A Focal Firm-Specific Analysis

Techno-economic and Life Cycle Analysis of the Modern Upstream Sustainable Lithium Supply Chain

An improved resource midpoint characterization method for supply risk of resources: integrated assessment of Li-ion batteries