Abstract:In this article I use Lacan's early theory of schizophrenia as corrected by the School of Leuven. Early in his career Lacan argued that schizophrenic people have a defective relation to language. Vergote and several of his students--all from Leuven--point out that schizophrenics also have a defective relation to their bodies. Lacan calls the defective relation to language a defect in the symbolic and he calls defective relations to the body a defect in the imaginary. Repairing defects in the symbolic requires introducing in the emotional life of the patient the paternal function of the law. Repairing the imaginary requires the more maternal help of mirroring, affirming, and holding. I underline that the two forms of healing that need to occur in the treatment of schizophrenics seem contradictory. I then proceed to demonstrate that two therapists, Bertram Karon--a non-Lacanian--and Palle Villemoes--a Lacanian-artfully combine the two contradictory strategies which are theoretically required. The remainder of the article is then devoted to a summary and a discussion of the different methods developed by these two therapists. I demonstrate that both do healing work at the imaginary level and the symbolic level. Sometimes these two therapists explicitly point out that they make a shift in their healing work with the patient; sometimes they do not alert the reader that they do so. I claim that in the work of both therapists it is the contradictory work at the level of the imaginary and of the symbolic that is healing, not the therapeutic intervention at the imaginary alone or at the symbolic alone.

Winnicott and Lacan: a missed encounter?

Thinking in the space between Winnicott and Lacan

Winnicott's invitation to 'further games of Jung-analysis'

Motherless Subjects and Mothered Selves: The Implications of Jacques Lacan’s and Donald Winnicott’s Writings on the Formation of the ‘I’ for American Studies

Interpretation and empathy: reading Lacan with Kohut

Winnicott's foundation for the basic concepts of Freud's metapsychology?

Giving Back What the Patient Brings: On Winnicott's "Mirror-Role of Mother and Family in Child Development"

Donald W. Winnicott’s Theory, Literature, and Migration

Models of reflexive recognition. Wallon's Origines du caractère and Lacan's "Mirror stage"

Introduction: Winnicott’s Collected Works, Volume 4

The grammar of paradox: Deciphering Winnicott's language theory

The Entanglement of Psychologism and Logicism-To Review the Intellectual History of the Relevant Disputations between E. Husserl and W. Wundt

Lacan's Construction and Deconstruction of the Double-Mirror Device

Playing in Time: A Discussion of Smadar Steinbock's "A Look at Chapter Four of Winnicott's Playing and Reality Through the Prism of its Modalities of Temporality"

Some Clinical Contributions of Jacques Lacan

A Lacanian explanation of Karon's and Villemoes's successful psychodynamic approaches to schizophrenia

The jouissance of the other and the prohibition of incest: a Lacanian perspective

"A Woman Who Found She Needed a Session of Indefinite Length": A Look at Chapter Four of Winnicott's Playing and Reality Through the Prism of its Modalities of Temporality

[The mirror stage ("Stade du Miroir" by J. Lacan) as a crucial stage of development for finding one's identity - normal, neurotic, psychotic development]

A thematic dialogue: towards a conclusion and a follow-up

Between Winnicot and Lacan: A Clinical Engagement