Early non-invasive ventilation treatment for severe influenza pneumonia

J R Masclans,M Pérez,J Almirall,L Lorente,A Marqués,L Socias,L Vidaur,J Rello,H1N1 GTEI/SEMICYUC Investigators,Pedro Cobo,Javier Martins,Cecilia Carbayo,Emilio Robles-Musso,Antonio Cárdenas,Javier Fierro,Dolores Ocaña Fernández,Rafael Sierra,Ma Jesús Huertos,Juan Carlos Pozo,R Guerrero,Reina Sofía,Enrique Márquez,Manuel Rodríguez-Carvajal,Juan Ramón Jiménez,Antonio Jareño,A Estella,José Pomares,José Luis Ballesteros,Yolanda Fernández,Francisco Lobato,José F Prieto,José Albofedo-Sánchez,Pilar Martínez,Miguel Angel Díaz Castellanos,Guillermo Sevilla,José Garnacho-Montero,Rafael Hinojosa,Esteban Fernández,Ana Loza,Cristóbal León,Angel Arenzana,Dolores Ocaña,Inés Navarrete,Medhi Zaheri Beryanaki,Ignacio Sánchez,Manuel Luis Avellanas,M I Marquina Lacueva,Pilar Luque,Lozano Blesa,Ignacio González,Miquel Servet,Jose Ma Montón,Obispo Polanco,Paloma Dorado Regil,Royo Villanova,Lisardo Iglesias,Carmen Pascual González,Águeda García-Rodríguez,Lorenzo Socias,Pedro Ibánez,Marcío Borges-Sa,A Socias,A Del Castillo,Ricard Jordà Marcos,José M Bonell,Ignacio Amestarán,Sergio Ruiz-Santana,Juan José Díaz,J Ferrer,Jordi Sole-Violan,José Molina,David Hernández,Ana Trujillo,Luis Regalado,Leonardo Lorente,Mar Martín,Sergio Martínez,J J Cáceres,Borja Suberviola,P Ugarte,Fernando García-López,Angel Álvaro Alonso,Antonio Pasilla,Luisa Gómez Grande,Antonio Albaya,Alfonso Canabal,Luis Marina,Almudena Simón,José María Añón,B López Messa,Ma Jesús López Pueyo,Zulema Ferreras,Santiago Macias,José Ángel Berezo,Jesús Blanco Varela,Andaluz Ojeda A,Antonio Álvarez Terrero,Fabiola Tena Ezpeleta,Zulema Paez,Álvaro García,Virgen Vega,Rosa Ma Catalán,Miquel Ferrer,Antoni Torres,Sandra Barbadillo,Lluís Cabré,Assumpta Rovira,Francisco Álvarez-Lerma,Antonia Vázquez,Joan Nolla,Francisco Fernández,Joaquim Ramón Cervelló,Rafael Mañéz,J Ballús,Rosa Ma Granada,Jordi Vallés,Marta Ortíz,C Guía,Fernando Arméstar,Joaquim Páez,Jordi Almirall,Xavier Balanzo,Elena Arnau,Cesar Laborda,Jessica Souto,Lluis Llopart,Ana Sanchez,Iñaki Catalán,Sant Joan de Déu,Josep Ma Sirvent,Cristina Ferri,Nerea López de Arbina,Josep Trueta,Mariona Badía,Montserrat Valverdú-Vidal,Fernando Barcenilla,Arnau de Vilanova,Mònica Magret,M F Esteban,José Luna,Juan Ma Nava,J González de Molina,Zoran Josic,Francisco Gurri,Jordi Rello,Alejandro Rodríguez,Thiago Lisboa,Diego de Mendoza,Ana Parra,Evelyn Garcia,Joan XXIII,Rosa María Díaz,Eduard Mesalles,Juliá-Narváez José,Infanta Cristina,Alberto Fernández-Zapata,Teresa Recio,Abilio Arrascaeta,José García-Ramos,Elena Gallego,Fernándo Bueno,Mercedes Díaz,Lourdes Cordero,José A Pastor,Luis Álvarez-Rocha,A Coruña,Dolores Vila,Ana Díaz Lamas,Javier Blanco Pérez,M Ortiz Piquer,Eleuterio Merayo,Victor Jose López-Ciudad,Juan Cortez,Eva Vilaboy,Eva Maria Saborido,Raul José González,Ana María López,Julio Canabal,Enrique Ferres,José Luis Monzón,Félix Goñi,Frutos Del Nogal Sáez,M Blasco Navalpotro,Severo Ochoa,Ma Carmen García-Torrejón,César Pérez-Calvo,Diego López,Luis Arnaiz,S Sánchez-Alonso,Carlos Velayos,Francisco del Río,Miguel Ángel González,María Cruz Martín,José Ma Molina,Juan Carlos Montejo,Mercedes Catalán,Patricia Albert,Ana de Pablo,José Eugenio Guerrero,Jaime Benitez Peyrat,Gregorio Marañón,Enrique Cerdá,Manuel Alvarez,Carlos Pey,Montse Rodríguez,Eduardo Palencia,Rafael Caballero,Concepción Vaquero,Francisco Mariscal,Susana García-Plaza,Nieves Carrasco,Isidro Prieto,A Liétor,R Ramos,Beatríz Galván,Juan C Figueira,M Cruz Soriano,P Galdós,Bárbara Balandin Moreno,Fernández del Cabo,Cecilia Hermosa,Federico Gordo,Alejandro Algora,Amparo Paredes,J A Cambronero,Sonia Gómez-Rosado,Luis Miguel Prado López,Sofía Martínez,F Felices Abad,Mariano Martínez,Sergio Manuel Butí,Bernardo Gil Rueda,Francisco García,Morales Messeguer,Enrique Maraví-Poma,I Jimenez Urra,L Macaya Redin,A Tellería,Josu Insansti,Nagore González,Pilar Marco,Loreto Vidaur,Emilio Perez-Trallero,B Santamaría,Juan Carlos Vergara,Jose Ramon Iruretagoyena Amiano,Alberto Manzano,Carlos Castillo Arenal,Pedro María Olaechea,José Blanquer,Roberto Reig Valero,A Belenger,Susana Altaba,Bernabé Álvarez-Sánchez,Alberto Picos,Ángel Sánchez-Miralles,Juan Bonastre,M Palamo,Javier Cebrian,José Cuñat,Belén Romero,Rafael Zaragoza,Virgilio Paricio,Asunción Marques,S Sánchez-Morcillo,S Tormo,J Latour,M Ángel García,Antoli Ribas
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-0691.2012.03797.x
Abstract:The role of non-invasive ventilation (NIV) in acute respiratory failure caused by viral pneumonia remains controversial. Our objective was to evaluate the use of NIV in a cohort of (H1N1)v pneumonia. Usefulness and success of NIV were assessed in a prospective, observational registry of patients with influenza A (H1N1) virus pneumonia in 148 Spanish intensive care units (ICUs) in 2009-10. Significant variables for NIV success were included in a multivariate analysis. In all, 685 patients with confirmed influenza A (H1N1)v viral pneumonia were admitted to participating ICUs; 489 were ventilated, 177 with NIV. The NIV was successful in 72 patients (40.7%), the rest required intubation. Low Acute Physiology and Chronic Health Evaluation (APACHE) II, low Sequential Organ Failure Assessment (SOFA) and absence of renal failure were associated with NIV success. Success of NIV was independently associated with fewer than two chest X-ray quadrant opacities (OR 3.5) and no vasopressor requirement (OR 8.1). However, among patients with two or more quadrant opacities, a SOFA score ≤7 presented a higher success rate than those with SOFA score >7 (OR 10.7). Patients in whom NIV was successful required shorter ventilation time, shorter ICU stay and hospital stay than NIV failure. In patients in whom NIV failed, the delay in intubation did not increase mortality (26.5% versus 24.2%). Clinicians used NIV in 25.8% of influenza A (H1N1)v viral pneumonia admitted to ICU, and treatment was effective in 40.6% of them. NIV success was associated with shorter hospital stay and mortality similar to non-ventilated patients. NIV failure was associated with a mortality similar to those who were intubated from the start.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?