Abstract:A widely used method for characterizing and comparing inefficiencies in perceptual processes is the method of equivalent internal noise--the amount of random internal noise necessary to produce the degree of inefficiency exhibited by the perceptual system in processing [J. Opt. Soc. Am. 46, 634 (1956)]. One normally estimates the amount of equivalent internal noise by systematically increasing the amount of external noise added to the signal stimulus and observing how threshold--signal stimulus energy required for an observer to maintain a given performance level--depends on the amount of external noise. In a variety of perceptual tasks, a simple noisy linear amplifier model [D. Pelli, Ph.D. dissertation (University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK 1981)] has been utilized to estimate the equivalent internal noise Ninternal by fitting of the relation between threshold contrast c tau and external noise N(ext) at a single (d') performance level: c tau 2 =(d'/beta)2(N(ext)2 + Ninternal2). This model makes a strong prediction: Independent of observer and external noise contrast, the ratio between two thresholds at each external noise level is equal to the ratio of the two corresponding d' values. To our knowledge, this potential test for the internal consistency of the model had never been examined previously. In this study we estimated threshold ratios between multiple performance levels at various external noise contrasts in two different experiments: Gabor orientation identification, and Gabor detection. We found that, in both identification and detection, the observed threshold ratios between different performance levels departed substantially from the d' ratio predicted by the simple noisy linear amplifier model. An elaborated perceptual template model [Vision Res. 38, 1183 (1998)] with nonlinear transducer functions and multiplicative noise in addition to the additive noise in the simple linear amplifier model leads to a substantially better description of the data and suggests a reinterpretation of earlier results that relied on the simple noisy linear amplifier model. The relationship of our model and method to other recent parallel and independent developments [J. Opt. Soc. Am. A 14, 2406 (1997)] is discussed.

Decision criteria in dual discrimination tasks estimated using external-noise methods

Human Decision Making Based on Variations in Internal Noise: an EEG Study.

Isolating objective and subjective filling-in using the drift diffusion model

Optimal metacognitive decision strategies in signal detection theory

Influence of reinforcement and its omission on trial‐by‐trial changes of response bias in perceptual decision making

Upshifted decision criteria in attentional blink and repetition blindness

A Semi-parametric Model for Decision Making in High-Dimensional Sensory Discrimination Tasks

Characterizing Human Perceptual Inefficiencies with Equivalent Internal Noise

Support for the Time-Varying Drift Rate Model of Perceptual Discrimination in Dynamic and Static Noise Using Bayesian Model-Fitting Methodology

Deciphering human decision rules in motion discrimination

The ideal observer: The forgotten second half of signal detection theory

Combining signal-detection theory and interaural cross-correlation approaches to account for the binaural abilities of normal-hearing listeners and listeners with “slight” hearing loss

Electrophysiological analysis of signal detection outcomes emphasizes the role of decisional factors in recognition memory

Spatial Attention Excludes External Noise at the Target Location

A decision-congruent heuristic gives superior metacognitive sensitivity under realistic variance assumptions.

Estimating the contribution of central noise from composite performance across multiple tasks

Dynamic noise estimation: A generalized method for modeling noise fluctuations in decision-making

Multiple-Event Forced-Choice Tasks in the Theory of Signal Detectability

Decision made, good feelings fade? How noise and multitasking affect decision confidence and well-being

What Determines Contrast Sensitivity: an External Noise Study Across Spatial Frequencies?