Absence of a BCS-BEC crossover in the cuprate superconductors

John Sous,Yu He,Steven A. Kivelson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41535-023-00550-1

2023-10-13

Abstract:We examine key aspects of the theory of the Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) to Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) crossover, focusing on the temperature dependence of the chemical potential, $\mu$. We identify an accurate method of determining the change of $\mu$ in the cuprate high temperature superconductors from angle-resolved-photoemission data (along the "nodal" direction), and show that $\mu$ varies by less than a few percent of the Fermi energy over a range of temperatures from far below to several times above the superconducting transition temperature, $T_c$. This shows, unambiguously, that not only are these materials always on the BCS side of the crossover (which is a phase transition in the $d-wave case), but are nowhere near the point of the crossover (where the chemical potential approaches the band bottom).

Superconductivity

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to determine whether cuprate superconductors are close to the transition from Bardeen - Cooper - Schrieffer (BCS) theory to Bose - Einstein condensation (BEC). Specifically, the authors explore this problem by analyzing the change of chemical potential (\(\mu\)) with temperature. They use angle - resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) data, especially the data along the "nodal" direction, to accurately measure the change of chemical potential. The study found that the chemical potential does not change much in the range from far below to several times the superconducting transition temperature \(T_c\), indicating that these materials are always on the BCS side and far from the BCS - to - BEC transition point.

### Main findings:
1. **Change of chemical potential**: The study found that in cuprate superconductors, the change of chemical potential \(\mu\) with temperature is very small, not exceeding a few percent of the Fermi energy. This result indicates that these materials are always on the BCS side, not close to the BEC limit.
2. **Existence of nodal quasiparticles**: Cuprate superconductors have d - wave symmetry and there are nodal - free quasiparticle excitations. In the BEC limit, such nodal quasiparticles do not exist. Therefore, the existence of nodal quasiparticles further proves that these materials are on the BCS side.
3. **Theoretical analysis**: Through the analysis of BCS theory, the authors show that in the BCS limit, the change of chemical potential is very small, and when approaching the BCS - to - BEC transition point, the chemical potential will drop significantly to the bottom of the band. The experimental results are consistent with the BCS theory expectations, further supporting the view that these materials are on the BCS side.

### Conclusion:
This study, through experimental and theoretical analysis, clearly shows that cuprate superconductors are always on the BCS side and far from the BCS - to - BEC transition point. This conclusion is of great significance for understanding the pairing mechanism and low - energy behavior of cuprate superconductors.