Abstract:The Li-Haldane correspondence [PRL 101, 010504 (2008)] is often used to help identify wave functions of (2+1)-D chiral topological phases (i.e., with non-zero chiral central charge) by studying low-lying entanglement spectra (ES) on long cylinders of finite circumference. Here we consider such ES of states [in fact, certain Projected Entangled Pair States (PEPS)] that are not chiral (i.e., having zero chiral central charge), but which strongly break time-reversal as well as reflection symmetry, while preserving their product, the same symmetry as a chiral state. This leads to ES with branches of both right- and left-moving chiralities, but with vastly different velocities. For circumferences much smaller than the inverse entanglement gap scale, the low-lying ES appear chiral in some topological sectors, and precisely follow the Li-Haldane state counting of a truly chiral phase. This could lead one to misidentify the phase as chiral. However, considering the ES in all sectors, one can observe distinct differences from a chiral phase. We explore this in an $SU(3)$ spin liquid PEPS studied by Kurečić, et al. [PRB 99, 045116 (2019)], where the topologically trivial sector has the state counting of a chiral $SU(3)$-level-one [$SU(3)_1$] Conformal Field Theory (CFT). In fact, the PEPS has $D(\mathbb{Z}_3)$ topological order, with 9 sectors. We compute the ES in minimally entangled states corresponding to these sectors, which map to the 9 anyon types of doubled $SU(3)_1$ Chern-Simons Topological Field Theory. The state countings of the ES coincide with our expectation: the ES contain irreps of global $SU(3)$ symmetry from the tensor products of the (lowest-lying) irrep of primary states of a "high-velocity" chiral $SU(3)_1$ CFT with the full content of a "low-velocity" chiral $SU(3)_1$ CFT sector, a non-chiral structure beyond that observable in the topologically trivial sector of the ES.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to identify the properties of these quantum states by studying the entanglement spectrum in non - chiral topological phases with strong time - reversal symmetry breaking. Specifically, the author focuses on the low - energy entanglement spectra with a finite perimeter on long cylinders, which belong to the wave functions of certain projected entangled pair states (PEPS). Although these states are non - chiral (i.e., the chiral central charge is zero), they strongly break time - reversal symmetry and reflection symmetry while retaining the product of these two symmetries. Therefore, these states exhibit the same symmetry characteristics as chiral topological states. The main objective of the paper is to explore whether the entanglement spectra of these non - chiral states can exhibit characteristics similar to chiral states through their low - energy parts, especially whether these low - energy entanglement spectra follow the state - counting rules in the Li - Haldane correspondence. If only specific topological sectors are considered, these low - energy entanglement spectra may be misidentified as the characteristics of chiral states. However, by analyzing all possible topological sectors, significant differences between these non - chiral states and true chiral states can be observed. To achieve this goal, the author uses a specific example, namely the SU(3) spin - liquid PEPS model studied by Kurečić et al. In this model, the low - energy entanglement spectra in the topologically trivial sector exhibit state - counting characteristics consistent with the chiral SU(3) level - one conformal field theory (CFT). However, by calculating the entanglement spectra of the minimally entangled states in all nine topological sectors, the author finds that the state - counting of these entanglement spectra is consistent with the expected, thus verifying that this PEPS model actually has non - chiral topological order. In summary, this paper aims to reveal the true properties of those "nearly chiral" non - chiral topological states through detailed entanglement spectrum analysis and provide a method to distinguish these states from true chiral states.

Entanglement spectra of non-chiral topological (2+1)-dimensional phases with strong time-reversal breaking, Li-Haldane state counting, and PEPS

Entanglement Spectrum as a diagnostic of chirality of Topological Spin Liquids: Analysis of an $\mathrm{SU}(3)$ PEPS

Interplay of $SU(2)$, point group and translation symmetry for PEPS: application to a chiral spin liquid

Chiral projected entangled-pair state with topological order

SU$(3)_1$ Chiral Spin Liquid on the Square Lattice: a View from Symmetric PEPS

Simulating chiral spin liquids with projected entangled-pair states

Critical Entanglement Spectrum of One-Dimensional Symmetry Protected Topological Phases

Tensor network states for the description of quantum many-body systems

Boson topological insulators: A window into highly entangled quantum phases

Chiral spin liquids with projected Gaussian fermionic entangled pair states

Long-Range Entanglement from Measuring Symmetry-Protected Topological Phases

Identifying Symmetry-Protected Topological Order By Entanglement Entropy

Symmetry-protected Topological Phases with Charge and Spin Symmetries: Response Theory and Dynamical Gauge Theory in Two and Three Dimensions

Partial fillings of the bosonic $E_8$ quantum Hall state

Non-Abelian topological order with SO(5)$_{1}$ chiral edge states

Composite Particle Theory of Three-Dimensional Gapped Fermionic Phases: Fractional Topological Insulators and Charge-Loop Excitation Symmetry

Generalized Lieb-Schultz-Mattis Theorem on Bosonic Symmetry Protected Topological Phases

Entanglement convertibility by sweeping through the quantum phases of the alternating bonds $XXZ$ chain

Quasiparticle Statistics And Braiding From Ground-State Entanglement