Recent Progress in Pencil Beam Scanning FLASH Proton Therapy: A Narrative Review

Shouyi Wei,Chengyu Shi,Chin-Cheng Chen,Sheng Huang,Robert H. Press,J. Isabelle Choi,Charles B. Simone II,Haibo Lin,Minglei Kang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2206.11722

2022-06-23

Abstract:Background and Objective: Recent experimental studies using ultra-high dose rate radiation therapy (FLASH-RT) have shown improved normal tissue sparing and comparable tumor control compared to conventional dose rate RT. Pencil beam scanning (PBS) proton therapy with superior dosimetry characteristics has begun to draw attention to the delivery of conformal FLASH-RT for preclinical studies. This review aims to provide recent updates on the development of PBS FLASH-RT. Methods: The information summarized in this review article is based on search results in databases such as PubMed and search engines like Google Scholar, with keywords including pencil beam scanning, proton therapy, proton FLASH, Bragg peak FLASH, etc., with English articles from the year of 2014-2022. Content and Findings: This review summarizes of recent developments in PBS FLASH proton therapy (FLASH-PT), including PBS dose rate characterization, current delivery limitations, treatment planning, and biological investigations. Conclusions: As PBS FLASH delivery has enabled successful biological studies using transmission beams, the further improvement in PBS Bragg peak FLASH technologies will result in more advanced treatment plans associated with potentially improved outcomes.

Medical Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: how to use Proton Pencil Beam Scanning (PBS) technology to achieve Ultra - High Dose - Rate FLASH radiotherapy (FLASH - RT), in order to improve the protection of normal tissues and maintain effective control of tumors. Specifically, the article explores the development and challenges of PBS FLASH proton therapy in the following aspects:

1. **Dose - rate characteristics**:
- How to achieve a high enough dose - rate (usually exceeding 40 Gy/s) to trigger the FLASH effect.
- The limitations of existing proton therapy systems in energy switching and beam - transport efficiency.

2. **Treatment planning and dose distribution**:
- How to optimize the treatment plan to ensure dose uniformity within the target area while minimizing the impact on surrounding normal tissues.
- The differences, advantages, and disadvantages between the transport beam and the Bragg - peak beam in terms of dose - rate and dose distribution.

3. **Biological - effect research**:
- The specific mechanism of the FLASH effect has not been fully clarified yet, but existing research has shown that it may be related to rapid oxygen depletion, reactive oxygen species (ROS) generation, and immune responses.
- Further biological research is required to verify these mechanisms and evaluate the safety and effectiveness of FLASH treatment.

4. **Clinical - application prospects**:
- Preliminary clinical trials have been launched to evaluate the feasibility and efficacy of FLASH PBS proton treatment in actual patients.
- Explore the optimal treatment regimens and dose - fractionation strategies for different parts (such as the head - and - neck, lungs, liver, etc.).

By reviewing the relevant research progress in recent years, this paper provides important guidance and references for the further development of PBS FLASH proton treatment in the future.

### Formula examples

To more clearly describe the dose - rate calculation methods, the article mentions several methods for quantifying the dose - rate, for example:

- **Dose - Averaged Dose Rate (DADR)**:
\[
\text{DADR}=\frac{\sum_i \text{Spot Dose Rate}_i\cdot w_i}{\sum_i w_i}
\]
where \(w_i\) is the dose - weight factor for each point.

- **Average Dose Rate (ADR)**:
\[
\text{ADR}=\frac{D_j - 2d^*}{T_j}
\]
where \(D_j\) is the total dose accumulated in voxel \(j\) during the irradiation time \(T_j\), and \(d^*\) is the preset dose threshold.

- **Dose Threshold Dose Rate (DTDR)**:
\[
\text{DTDR}=\frac{\sum_i \text{Spot Dose Rate}_i\cdot I(\text{Dose}>d^*)}{\sum_i I(\text{Dose}>d^*)}
\]
where \(I(\text{Dose}>d^*)\) is an indicator function, which is 1 when the dose is greater than the threshold \(d^*\), and 0 otherwise.

These formulas help researchers better understand and optimize the dose - rate distribution in PBS FLASH proton treatment.