Coarse Wage-Setting and Behavioral Firms

Germán Reyes

2024-03-27

Abstract:This paper shows that the bunching of wages at round numbers is partly driven by firm coarse wage-setting. Using data from over 200 million new hires in Brazil, I first establish that contracted salaries tend to cluster at round numbers. Then, I show that firms that tend to hire workers at round-numbered salaries have worse market outcomes. Next, I develop a wage-posting model in which optimization costs lead to the adoption of coarse rounded wages and provide evidence supporting two model predictions using two research designs. Finally, I examine some consequences of coarse wage-setting for relevant economic outcomes.

General Economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the phenomenon of wage bunching at integer values and whether this phenomenon is driven by firms' non-standard wage-setting behavior. Specifically, the author explores the following questions by analyzing data from over 200 million new hires in Brazil:

1. **Existence of Wage Bunching**: Is there a significant concentration of workers' contract wages at integer values?
2. **Impact of Firm Behavior**: Is this wage bunching phenomenon caused by firms adopting rough, suboptimal methods when setting wages? If so, how do these firms perform in the market?
3. **Economic Consequences**: What are the impacts of this rough wage-setting method on internal wage inequality, nominal wage rigidity, and policies related to wage distribution (such as minimum wage adjustments)?

### Main Research Content

1. **Data and Methods**:
- Utilized administrative data from Brazil's formal sector from 2003 to 2017, including contract wage information for over 200 million new hires.
- Analyzed the concentration of contract wages at integer values in this data.

2. **Empirical Results**:
- **Wage Bunching**: The data shows a significant concentration of contract wages at integer values, for example, 33.8% of new hires have contract wages that are integers (under a uniform distribution, it should be 10%).
- **Firm Behavior**: Defined a category of "bunching firms" that tend to hire employees with integer wages. The study found that these bunching firms perform worse in the market, with higher employee turnover rates, lower employment growth rates, and higher market exit rates.
- **Economic Consequences**: Further examined the impact of this rough wage-setting method on economic outcomes, such as increased wage compression within firms and greater nominal wage rigidity.

### Research Contributions

1. **Validated the Wage Bunching Phenomenon**: Confirmed the existence of wage bunching at integer values using administrative data, ruling out the possibility of measurement error.
2. **Explained Firm Behavior**: Provided evidence that this bunching phenomenon is partly driven by firms' non-standard wage-setting behavior rather than exploiting employees' behavioral biases.
3. **Analyzed Economic Consequences**: Quantified the impact of rough wage-setting methods on economic outcomes, offering new insights into wage-setting models.

### Conclusion

Through extensive data and rigorous empirical analysis, the paper reveals the non-standard firm behavior behind the wage bunching phenomenon and explores its impact on economic outcomes. These findings not only help in understanding the wage-setting process but also have significant implications for labor market modeling assumptions and related policy-making.