Abstract:We study the effects of data sharing between firms on prices, profits, and consumer welfare. Although indiscriminate sharing of consumer data decreases firm profits due to the subsequent increase in competition, selective sharing can be beneficial. We show that there are data-sharing mechanisms that are strictly Pareto-improving, simultaneously increasing firm profits and consumer welfare. Within the class of Pareto-improving mechanisms, we identify one that maximizes firm profits and one that maximizes consumer welfare.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to solve the problems of incentives and benefits for enterprises in data sharing. Specifically, the paper explores the impact of consumer data sharing between enterprises on corporate profits and consumer welfare. Although sharing consumer data indiscriminately will lead to a decline in corporate profits due to increased competition, selectively sharing certain data can improve the welfare of both enterprises and consumers at the same time. The main contribution of the paper lies in designing a strictly Pareto - improving data - sharing mechanism, which can not only increase corporate profits but also enhance consumer welfare.
### Background and Problems of the Paper
In the e - commerce environment, enterprises possess different types of consumer data. If these data are shared indiscriminately among enterprises, it will lead to intensified market competition and thus reduce corporate profits. However, through a carefully - designed data - sharing mechanism, the welfare of both enterprises and consumers can be improved simultaneously without harming the interests of any party.
### Research Methods
The paper uses a classic Hotelling model to study the impact of data sharing. In this model, two enterprises are respectively located at the two ends of a unit interval (from 0 to 1), and consumers are distributed on this interval. Each consumer purchases goods from one of the two enterprises and pays the price and transportation cost. Enterprises can provide personalized prices according to the known location of consumers.
### Main Findings
1. **Indiscriminate Data Sharing**: When enterprises share all consumer data indiscriminately, market efficiency and consumer welfare will increase, but corporate profits will decline. Therefore, enterprises are reluctant to participate in such comprehensive data sharing.
2. **Partial Data Sharing**: The paper proposes a partial data - sharing mechanism, that is, enterprises only share specific data of some consumers. In this way, a mechanism can be designed so that while enterprises increase their profits, the welfare of consumers can also be enhanced.
3. **Pareto - Improving Mechanism**: The paper designs a strictly Pareto - improving data - sharing mechanism, which can improve the welfare of both enterprises and consumers simultaneously without harming the interests of any party. Specifically, the paper shows how to achieve a dual improvement in the welfare of enterprises and consumers by selectively sharing the data of certain consumers.
### Conclusions
Through theoretical analysis and model construction, the paper proves that in the e - commerce environment, through a carefully - designed data - sharing mechanism, the competitive barriers between enterprises can be overcome and a win - win situation for the welfare of enterprises and consumers can be achieved. This finding is of great significance for promoting data sharing and the development of the digital economy.
### Formulas and Models
To show the mathematical models in the paper more clearly, the following are the Markdown representations of some key formulas:
- Consumer utility function:
\[
u(\theta, p_i, \theta_i)=v - p_i - t|\theta - \theta_i|
\]
where \(\theta\) is the location of the consumer, \(p_i\) is the price of enterprise \(i\), \(\theta_i\) is the location of enterprise \(i\), and \(t\) is the marginal transportation cost.
- Profit maximization of enterprises without data sharing:
\[
\pi_A = p_A\cdot\left(\frac{1}{2}-\frac{p_A}{2t}\right)
\]
\[
\pi_B=\int_{1 / 4}^{1}t(2\theta - 1/2)\,d\theta=\frac{9t}{16}
\]
- Profits of enterprises in the case of partial data sharing:
\[
\pi_A = t\left(\frac{1}{4}-\epsilon^2\right)
\]
\[
\pi_B = t\left(\frac{3}{4}-\epsilon\right)
\]
- Consumer welfare:
\[
CW=\int_0^1\max\{v - \theta t - p_A, v - t(1 - \theta)-p_B(\theta)\}\,d\theta = v - t\left(\frac{5}{