Abstract:Criminal investigations, particularly sexual assaults, frequently require the identification of body fluid type in addition to body fluid donor to provide context. In most cases this can be achieved by conventional methods, however, in certain scenarios, alternative molecular methods are required. An example of this is the detection of menstrual fluid and vaginal material, which are not able to be identified using conventional techniques. Endpoint reverse-transcription PCR (RT-PCR) is currently used for this purpose to amplify body fluid specific messenger RNA (mRNA) transcripts in forensic casework. Real-time quantitative reverse-transcription PCR (RT-qPCR) is a similar method but utilises fluorescent markers to generate quantitative results in the form of threshold cycle (C q ) values. Despite the uncertainty surrounding body fluid identification, most interpretation guidelines utilise categorical statements. Probabilistic modelling is more realistic as it reflects biological variation as well as the known performance of the method. This research describes the application of various machine learning models to single-source mRNA profiles obtained by RT-qPCR and assesses their performance. Multinomial logistic regression (MLR), Naïve Bayes (NB), and linear discriminant analysis (LDA) were used to discriminate between the following body fluid categories: saliva, circulatory blood, menstrual fluid, vaginal material, and semen. We identified that the performance of MLR was somewhat improved when the quantitative dataset of the original C q values was used (overall accuracy of approximately 0.95) rather than presence/absence coded data (overall accuracy of approximately 0.94). This indicates that the quantitative information obtained by RT-qPCR amplification is useful in assigning body fluid class. Of the three classification methods, MLR performed the best. When we utilised receiver operating characteristic curves to observe performance by body fluid class, it was clear that all methods found difficulty in classifying menstrual blood samples. Future work will involve the modelling of body fluid mixtures, which are common in samples analysed as part of sexual assault investigations.

Calculating LRs for presence of body fluids from mRNA assay data in mixtures

Developing an interpretation model for body fluid identification

Complex DNA mixture analysis in a forensic context: evaluating the probative value using a likelihood ratio model

Differentiation of five forensically relevant body fluids using a small set of microRNA markers

Comparing endpoint and real-time PCR for forensic body fluid identification

Identification of Mixtures of Two Types of Body Fluids Using the Multiplex Methylation System and Random Forest Models

Comprehensive body fluid identification and contributor assignment by combining targeted sequencing of mRNA and coding region SNPs

Micro RNA Profiling for the Detection and Differentiation of Body Fluids in Forensic Stain Analysis

Forensic validation of a combined analysis of mRNA and miRNA markers for precise tissue origin inferences of five kinds of body fluids by RT‐qPCR

A systematic analysis of miRNA markers and classification algorithms for forensic body fluid identification

mRNA for Body Fluid and Individual Identification

Development of a Multiplex System for the Identification of Forensically Relevant Body Fluids.

Developmental validation of an mRNA kit: A 5-dye multiplex assay designed for body-fluid identification

Bacterial profile-based body fluid identification using a machine learning approach

A data-driven, high-throughput methodology to determine tissue-specific differentially methylated regions able to discriminate body fluids

Development of Highly Sensitive and Specific Mrna Multiplex System (XCYR1) for Forensic Human Body Fluids and Tissues Identification

Evaluation of the Inclusion of Circular RNAs in Mrna Profiling in Forensic Body Fluid Identification

Body Fluid Identification by Nanoparticle Enhanced LDI MS

Design and optimization of a 16S microbial qPCR multiplex for the presumptive identification of feces, saliva, vaginal and menstrual secretions

Phenotypic Profiling Based on Body Fluid Traces Discovered at the Scene of Crime: Raman Spectroscopy of Urine Stains for Race Differentiation

Evaluation of the Microbiome Identification of Forensically Relevant Biological Fluids: A Pilot Study